TSN TV Schedule TSN2 TV Schedule
Blogs

McKenzie: Examining the logic behind Central Scouting rankings

Bob McKenzie
4/7/2010 7:07:58 PM
Decrease Text SizeIncrease Text Size
Text Size

With Taylor Hall and the Windsor Spitfires running roughshod over Tyler Seguin and the Plymouth Whalers in the OHL playoffs, some may be confused at how NHL Central Scouting has Seguin ranked No. 1 ahead of Hall on the final rankings for the 2010 draft.

While it's clear Hall has outplayed Seguin in this latest head to head meeting, scouts are charged with identifying the best prospects for the future - not necessary the best player right now.

And by virtue of the No. 1 ranking, NHL central scouting has effectively tabbed Seguin as the best future consideration.

That's probably a minority opinion with scouts who work for NHL teams, but it's not out of left field by any means. I know for a fact that at least a couple of teams which will pick in the Top 10 of the draft have Seguin rated ahead of Hall.

The point is, in spite of how the OHL playoffs have unfolded - with Hall and the Spitfires dominating Seguin and the Whalers - it's very close between these top two elite prospects. There's no slam dunk for No. 1 this year.

Perhaps the bigger surprise is Windsor defenceman Cam Fowler dropping to No. 5 on the final list.

Fowler ranks behind Prince George forward Brett Connolly, who has been injured much of the season but is playing for Canada at the Under-18 world championship next week. Kingston defenceman Erik Gudbranson, who will also play in the Under-18, is ranked fourth.

Fowler has been the consensus No. 1 defenceman for most of the season, but Gudbranson has eclipsed him in the eyes of Central Scouting and some but not all NHL team scouts.

Gudbranson plays a harder, physical game but many club team scouts still have Fowler as the No. 1 blueliner.

TSN will come out with a new Top 10 ranking on Monday - the day before the NHL draft lottery.

Bob McKenzie

Podcasts

TSN 690 Montreal - Morning Show - Bob McKenzie (06-19-2013)

Ted & Elliott are joined by TSN hockey insider Bob McKenzie to discuss the Stanley Cup finals, and the goings on in the NHL.

TSN 1050 Toronto: TSN Drive with Dave Naylor- Hour 2: June 17th

Dave is joined by TSN Hockey Insider Bob McKenzie, Bruce Arthur of The National Post and former Toronto Raptors Player & Scout Alvin Williams

TSN 1050 Toronto: TSN Drive with Dave Naylor- Bob McKenzie: June 17th

TSN Hockey Insider Bob McKenzie speculated where a team would be located if Phoenix did not come to an agreement.


More Podcasts

Follow Us!

There's a new Twitter feed that will make you a real TSN.ca insider! Follow twitter.com/TSN_Sports_Buzz to get updates on the latest blogs, best videos and more!


More about TSN on Twitter...

The semifinals continue as Detroit's Pavel Datsyuk faces Cody Hodgson of the Sabres.
Watch the video and vote for your favourite play!


Stanley Cup Final

(1) Chicago Blackhawks vs. (4) Boston Bruins

Boston leads series 2-1 - Game 4 tonight


You can also chat and get updates from TSN's hockey personalities with TSN.ca's Game Night blog on the TSN GameTracker every night during the postseason.

The NBA Finals

(1) Miami Heat vs. (2) San Antonio Spurs

Series tied 3-3 - Game 7 Thursday on TSN

2013 CFL Team Previews

Get caught up on all the information that shaped each team in the off-season, and what to expect from them in the season to come.


West Division
BC Lions
Edmonton Eskimos
Calgary Stampeders
Saskatchewan Roughriders

East Division
Winnipeg Blue Bombers
Toronto Argonauts
Hamilton Tiger-Cats
Montreal Alouettes

Knowledge and Performance

A look at Brooke Henderson, a 15-year-old golfer from Smith's Falls, Ontario who has qualified for this year's U.S. Women's Open. More...

TSN Promotions
Make Your Predictions!
Take The Challenge!
Make Your Predictions!
TSN Stock Car Challenge
The Ultimate Lotus F1 Team Experience