TSN TV Schedule TSN2 TV Schedule
Columnists

McKenzie: NHL GMs to discuss aspects of fighting

Bob McKenzie
1/20/2009 7:03:12 PM
Decrease Text SizeIncrease Text Size
Text Size

In the wake of the Don Sanderson tragedy, the National Hockey League says it is going to discuss "all aspects" of fighting when general managers meet in Florida this March.

But the real question is how much of an appetite is there for anything approximating real change when it comes to rules and attitudes governing fighting in the NHL?

TSN conducted a flash survey of NHL general managers to get a sense where they currently stand on the issue - and it's clear that change will not come easily.

Asked if they favoured "stiffer punishment" for any player who fights, only two of the 18 executives who responded to the survey said yes. And of those two, neither said they would be in favor of automatically ejecting any player who fights in an NHL game.

The 16 general managers who voted against "stiffer punishment" were then asked if they were in favor of abolishing the instigator rule - that is, change the rules to possibly promote more fighting - and five of the 16 said yes to that. That wouldn't be enough to affect change, but it's interesting that five general managers favour getting rid of the instigator and only two voted in favor of stronger anti-fighting measures.

The issue that is likely to have the most meaningful dialogue concerns the Ontario Hockey League's recent helmet rule, where players who voluntarily remove their helmets for a fight get ejected and suspended and linesmen are instructed to stop any fight where a player's helmet accidentally comes off.

Eleven of the 18 general managers said they were opposed to the OHL helmet rule, but the fact that seven voted in favor of it suggests there is perhaps at least some basis for discussion on that.

 

Bob McKenzie

Podcasts

TSN 1050 Toronto: TSN Drive with Dave Naylor - Hour 2: May 17th

Dave and Kate Beirness are joined by TSN Hockey Insider Bob McKenzie, TSN Legal Analyst Eric Macramella, and TSN 1050 Jays reporter Scott MAcArthur.

TSN 1050 Toronto: TSN Drive with Dave Naylor - Bob McKenzie: May 17th

TSN Hockey Insider Bob McKenzie updated the status of Jason Spezza and Eric Staal.

TSN 1050 Toronto: TSN Drive with Dave Naylor - Hour 2: May 15th

Mike Hogan is joined by TSN Hockey Insider, Bruce Arthur of The National Post, and Richard Griffin of The Toronto Star.


More Podcasts

Follow Us!

There's a new Twitter feed that will make you a real TSN.ca insider! Follow twitter.com/TSN_Sports_Buzz to get updates on the latest blogs, best videos and more!


More about TSN on Twitter...

Round 1 continues with the Blue Jackets' Marian Gaborik taking on Magnus Paajarvi of the Oilers.
Watch the video and vote for your favourite play!


Eastern Conference Semifinals

(1) Pittsburgh Penguins vs. (7) Ottawa Senators

Penguins lead series 2-1

(4) Boston Bruins vs. (6) New York Rangers

Bruins lead series 2-0


Western Conference Semifinals

(1) Chicago Blackhawks vs. (7) Detroit Red Wings

Series tied 1-1

(5) Los Angeles Kings vs. (6) San Jose Sharks

Kings lead series 2-1



Eastern Conference Finals

(1) Miami Heat vs. (3) Indiana Pacers

Series starts Wednesday


Western Conference Finals

(2) San Antonio Spurs vs. (5) Memphis Grizzlies

Spurs lead series 1-0

Knowledge and Performance

A look at Albin Choi, a 20-year-old from Toronto, Ontario, who was named Canada's top male amateur golfer in 2012. More...

TSN Promotions
Make Your Predictions!
Enter Now!
Take The Challenge!
Make Your Predictions!
TSN Stock Car Challenge
The Ultimate Lotus F1 Team Experience