Schultz: Comparing my NFL season predictions to reality

Chris Schultz
1/3/2012 2:02:09 PM
Decrease Text SizeIncrease Text Size
Text Size

It's that time in the season when I look back at my pre-season NFL predictions and compare my thoughts at the time to the current reality.  I have yet to meet anyone who can predict the NFL with 100% accuracy and I highly doubt that I ever will.

When I made my picks in August, I was using both logic and feel, which I know is a contradiction, but I figured it would be the best way to go.

Let's see how I did.

NFC East

Prediction: 1. Philadelphia, 2. Dallas, 3. NY Giants, 4. Washington
Actual: 1. NY Giants (9-7), 2. Philadelphia (8-8), 3. Dallas (8-8), 4. Washington (5-11)

The story of the NFC East this season was that the Eagles could not capitalize on all the free agent talent they purchased in the offseason.  The second story was the emergence of Eli Manning at quarterback for the Giants.  Both the Eagles and Giants defeated the Cowboys both home and away, and those four losses took Dallas from a possible 12-4 to their 8-8 record and no playoff opportunity


Prediction: 1. St. Louis, 2. Seattle, 3. Arizona, 4. San Francisco
Actual: 1. San Francisco (13-3), 2. Arizona (8-8), 3. Seattle (7-9), 4. St. Louis  (2-14)

I have no defence for my prediction in this division.  I honestly believed that St. Louis would win the division and that the 49ers would finish last.  The reality is that the 49ers have a first round bye in the playoffs and allowed the fewest points in the NFL (202), while only losing three times.  Once again, I have no defence for my pre-season pick here.

NFC North

Prediction: 1. Green Bay, 2. Detroit, 3. Chicago, 4. Minnesota
Actual: 1. Green Bay (15-1), 2. Detroit (10-6), 3. Chicago (8-8), 4. Minnesota (3-13)

This was an easy division to predict, as everyone knew how good Green Bay was, and how much Detroit had improved.  Minnesota was rebuilding and the Bears were all about quarterback Jay Cutler.  They were 7-3 when Cutler got hurt, and they finished the year with an 8-8 record.  That tells you all you need to know.

NFC South

Prediction: 1. Atlanta, 2. New Orleans, 3. Tampa Bay, 4. Carolina
Actual: 1. New Orleans (13-3), 2. Atlanta (10-6), 3. Carolina (6-10), 4. Tampa Bay (4-12)

I should have put my faith in Brees and the Saints, but I thought this would be Atlanta's year.  The Panthers are going to improve from their 6-10 record this year because of soon-to-be rookie of the year Cam Newton and his growth at quarterback.  The Buccaneers went from a 10 win team in 2010, to a 4 win team this year. 

AFC East

Prediction: 1. New England, 2. NY Jets, 3. Buffalo, 4. Miami
Actual: 1. New England (13-3), 2. NY Jets (8-8), 3. Miami (6-10), 4. Buffalo (6-10)

The story of the AFC East are the New York Jets.  After two straight AFC Championship appearances, they finished the year out of the playoffs at 8-8.  The other story in the division is the New England Patriots, who will need to continue to outscore everyone if they want to progress in the playoffs.  The Bills regressed after September, while the Dolphins improved in December.  Either way, this should be the Patriots division for years to come.

AFC West

Prediction: 1. San Diego, 2. Kansas City, 3. Denver, 4. Oakland
Actual: 1. Denver (8-8), 2. Oakland (8-8), 3. San Diego (8-8), 4. Kansas City (7-9)

Tim Tebow was the surprise of the division and not for his ability at the quarterback position, but rather his personality and beliefs.  San Diego was a surprise 8-8, as they have a much higher level of talent than that record shows.  Jeff Fisher is most likely the number one candidate if the Chargers should fire coach Norv Turner.

AFC North

Prediction: 1. Pittsburgh, 2. Cleveland, 3. Baltimore, 4. Cincinnati  
Actual: 1. Baltimore (12-4), 2. Pittsburgh (12-4), 3. Cincinnati (9-7), 4. Cleveland (4-12)

Well, I guess it's safe to say that I completely underrated the Baltimore Ravens and totally overrated the Cleveland Browns.  I also did not see the excellence that rookies Andy Dalton and A.J. Green would bring to the Bengals.  The Ravens may be the toughest team in football and they'll be tough to beat with rest in the Divisional playoff game.

AFC South

Prediction: 1. Houston, 2. Tennessee, 3. Indianapolis, 4. Jacksonville
Actual: 1. Houston (10-6), 2. Tennessee (9-7), 3. Jacksonville (5-11), 4. Indianapolis (2-14)

I don't know which is the most significant story:  the Texans winning the division and making the playoffs for the first time in franchise history, or the complete and total regression of the Colts without Peyton Manning.  The only saving grace for the Colts is that they can now draft Andrew Luck, who could be the next great quarterback and would immediately serve as insurance because you don't really know what to expect from Manning in 2012.

Just for fun, here is a comparison for what my top 6 predictions were in August for each conference in comparison to reality.

NFC Playoff Teams

Prediction: 1. Green Bay, 2. Atlanta, 3. Philadelphia, 4. St. Louis, 5. New Orleans, 6. Dallas
Actual: 1. Green Bay, 2. San Francisco, 3. New Orleans, 4. NY Giants, 5. Atlanta, 6. Detroit

AFC Playoff Teams

Prediction: 1. San Diego, 2. New England, 3. Pittsburgh, 4. Houston, 5. NY Jets, 6. Kansas City
Actual: 1. New England, 2. Baltimore, 3. Houston, 4. Denver, 5. Pittsburgh, 6. Cincinnati

My Super Bowl prediction was the San Diego Chargers over the Green Bay Packers.  I have no excuses.

Chris Schultz

Chris Schultz


TSN 1050: Mike Richards In the Morning: Bob Mackenzie - June 25

TSN Insider joins the program to talk free agency and draft day

TSN 1050: Mike Richards in the Morning - Chris Schultz: September 13

Mike Richards in the Morning is joined by Chris Schultz to talk NFL and CFL football.

TSN 1050 Toronto: TSN Drive with Dave Naylor- John Clayton: June 20th

ESPN NFL writer John Clayton joined the program to discuss all things around the league.

More Podcasts

Follow Us!

There's a new Twitter feed that will make you a real insider! Follow to get updates on the latest blogs, best videos and more!

More about TSN on Twitter...

Cabbie on

Cabbie catches up with some NHLers as they try out the new NHL 15 video game. The players react to their ratings, attributes and likenesses. More...

He has speed in his DNA, learn more about Olympic champion Donovan Bailey's nephew, Jaden and his success on the gridiron in the latest Powerade 24. More...

© 2014
All rights reserved.
Bell Media Television