TSN TV Schedule TSN2 TV Schedule
Columnists

Dreger: Carbonneau's firing a complicated decision

Darren Dreger
3/9/2009 8:09:23 PM
Decrease Text SizeIncrease Text Size
Text Size

Guy Carbonneau's firing isn't as simple as the Montreal Canadiens needing a new voice or a late season change in direction.

As is often the case when an NHL coach is let go in-season, there's much more to it than that.

There's too much respect for Carbonneau for anyone inside the Montreal organization to pick at his carcass, but his firing with just 16 regular season games remaining came as no surprise to some, while others speculate Carbonneau's firing may have been encouraged by ownership.

Sources say Carbonneau struggled when it came to communicating with his players and tried to avoid any dialogue with a player that may have led to confrontation.  Because of this, at times, sources say the players felt the distance and in certain instances, retreated.

Canadiens star Alex Kovalev was banished for two games last month after Bob Gainey stepped in and forced him to stay home from a road trip, hoping to re-ignite his star forward's passion.

Some suggest that situation and the publicity circus that followed could have been avoided with better communication between coach and player.

Gainey says his decision to intervene and attempt to rectify the issues plaguing Kovalev was made following a meeting with his coaching staff.

Although the Canadiens have managed to stay in the playoff mix, Montreal hasn't played well for a long time and for reasons that extend well beyond a failure to communicate, the players were no longer playing for Guy Carbonneau, or as Gainey stated, "emotionally the team was no longer engaged".

Hence, it's Bob Gainey's job to fix what ultimately cost Guy Carbonneau his job.

Darren Dreger

Podcasts

NHL Insider - February 4

Did the Thrashers get enough for Ilya Kovalchuk? NHL Insider Darren Dreger breaks down the deal.

NHL Insider - January 12

NHL Insider Darren Dreger discusses the end result of Alex Burrows' tirade on referee Staphane Auger.

NHL Insider - December 10

NHL Insider Darren Dreger breaks down the potential sale of the Coyotes to the Ice Edge group.

Follow Us!

There's a new Twitter feed that will make you a real TSN.ca insider! Follow twitter.com/TSN_Sports_Buzz to get updates on the latest blogs, best videos and more!


More about TSN on Twitter...

poker
Click here

Photo Galleries

Photo Gallery

Super Bowl XLIV - See the best images from the biggest game of the NFL season. Launch Gallery

tsn ie8
hockey pool

Podcasts

Rapid Fire Reporters 2.0 - February 7

The Reporters preview the Olympic hockey tournament and discuss the role goaltending could play.

The Reporters - February 7

The Reporters discuss the Super Bowl, the Olympic hockey tournament, blockbuster trades and more.

Off the Record - February 5

Former NFL running back Tiki Barber is Up Front and the panel talks about their predictions for the Super Bowl.