Cullen's Blog: The case for 1993

Scott Cullen
5/19/2009 10:04:01 AM
Decrease Text SizeIncrease Text Size
Text Size

When Double Play Baseball Blogger Dave Carroll asked me to figure out which team was better, the 1992 or 1993 Blue Jays, I liked the idea of breaking down the numbers, 16 years after the fact, to see which squad was better.

The 1993 team had a superior lineup, with a career season for 1B John Olerud, a breakthrough year for 2B Roberto Alomar and a better year from CF Devon White all counting significantly. 

Additionally, SS Tony Fernandez, DH Paul Molitor and 3B Ed Sprague were all more productive than their 1992 counterparts -- Manny Lee, Dave Winfield and Kelly Gruber, respectively.

C Pat Borders and RF Joe Carter were both fairly similar in '92 and '93, leaving 1992 Candy Maldonado vs. 1993 Rickey Henderson as the one possible advantage for the '92 team.  Since Henderson slumped after he was acquired from Oakland, it's possible that the Candy Man might hold a small advantage (by ignoring Henderson's production in Oakland), but that would be a best-case scenario for the 1992 team.  Given the choice, I still believe that a vast majority would prefer Henderson. 

Overall, that decisively favours the lineup for the 1993 team.

At the same time, the 1992 pitching staff was clearly better (3.92 ERA compared to 4.22 ERA in '93).  The one starter who was crucial to both teams, Juan Guzman, was much better in '92 and the trio of Jack Morris, David Cone and Jimmy Key holds an edge over Pat Hentgen, Dave Stewart and Todd Stottlemyre (who was the No. 5 starter in '92 once Cone arrived).

The bullpen was another advantage for 1992, but maybe not by as much as one might think.  The '92 team was dominant in the eighth and ninth innings with Duane Ward setting up Tom Henke, while the '93 team had more of a committee setup role with Danny Cox, Mark Eichhorn, Mike Timlin and Tony Castillo all playing significant bullpen roles. 

However, Ward the closer in 1993 was every bit as good as Henke the closer in 1992, which helps to minimize the overall pitching difference between the two teams. 

Furthermore, having the lights-out bullpen at game's end plays to an advantage more if the team is already leading and, based on the lineups, my evaluation is that the '93 team would have the lead more often.

Over an anticipated seven-game series, it's just hard to fathom even the 1992 staff being able to shut down WAMCO at its peak. 

When I put the numbers into the spreadsheet I use to generate the Power Rankings, the results favoured the '93 team by a -125 margin (five wins for every four wins by the '92 squad), a small enough difference to expect a close series, but we already knew that, right?

Paul Molitor (Photo: Simon Barnett/Getty Images)


(Photo: Simon Barnett/Getty Images)
Share This

Share This

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to FarkAdd to TwitterAdd to Stumble UponAdd to Reddit
Print this Story

Blue Jays: 1992 vs. 1993

1992 vs. 1993

The Blue Jays treated their fans to something special with back-to-back World Series Championships in 1992 and 1993, but which squad was superior?

'92 or '93: Which team was tops?

Tale of the Tape

Double Play: Case for 1992

Cullen: Case for 1993

Those wild October nights in the '90s

Photo Gallery
Back-to-Back Championships

Blue Jays on TSN Broadcast Schedule

Baseball Canada

Keep up with the latest on Canada's national programs from the governing body for amateur baseball in Canada.

Baseball Canada Website


TSN 1050: The Baseball Podcast : Episode 17 - Aug. 6th

Scott MacArthur, Richard Griffin & Gregor Chisholm discuss quiet trade deadline for the Blue Jays, struggling rotation & potential Biogenesis fallout.

TSN 1050: The Baseball Podcast: July 30 - Episode 15

Scott MacArthur & Toronto Star's Richard Griffin preview the trade deadline, Blue Jays' needs & being on Boston as Jon Lester rumours ramp up.

TSN 1050: Blue Lunch: July 9 - John McDonald

LA Angels infielder, John McDonald joined Blue Lunch to discuss his career from the time he left Toronto to the present.

More Podcasts

© 2014
All rights reserved.
Bell Media Television