In one of the closest votes yet, Steven Stamkos and his mid-air goal eked out a win over Pavel Datsyuk's shootout goal. Stamkos will move on the Play of the Year Showdown Final.
Watch the video to see how he did it.
Don't forget to check out the full bracket below on the right, make your comments heard with the TSN.ca Your Call feature below and share your pick on Facebook.
Semi-Final #1
Steven Stamkos
Tampa Bay Lightning
Pavel Datsyuk
Detroit Red Wings