TSN TV Schedule TSN2 TV Schedule
NHL

McKenzie: A reoccuring debate in the 2009 playoffs

{eot}
Bob McKenzie
5/1/2009 9:45:04 PM
Decrease Text SizeIncrease Text Size
Text Size

In the first period of the series opener between the Red Wings and Ducks, Anaheim forward Mike Brown delivered a big hit on Detroit's Jiri Hudler. The result of which was Hudler facedown and bleeding on the ice.

The referee deemed that this was a late hit. There was a five-minute penalty for interference as they're allowed to call it. The question now is whether Brown will be punished further by the league.

If you go by what the general managers discuss, when they have their meetings, they say just because a guy has a free shot on a guy in the neutral zone, doesn't mean that you can take it every time, if he's in a vulnerable position and there's injury. The traditional view is keep your head up because if you're the last guy to touch the puck, you're fair game. There's really that conflict between those views and I don't know that they've ever fully come to terms with it in the National Hockey League.

Now the reason that Donald Brashear got five games was because it was such a severe injury. In last night's game, Ben Eager stepped up in the neutral zone on Rick Rypien and very similar type hit to what happened with Hudler, but Rypien wasn't injured. Eager got a two-minute minor instead of a five-minute major and there was no suspension for Eager.

I can tell you this, the Red Wings will be furious with this play. They will say it's a case of a marginal player, in this case a fourth liner Brown, targeting one of their skill players early in a series to try to send a message and take him out of the game. The Ducks will come back and say that's good tough hockey, keep your head up, don't admire your pass and everything is going to be fine.

It's really up to the National Hockey League to decide what is it that they want to do. I think the NHL is going to look at it and say it's a five-minute major, it happened midway through the first period, Mike Brown is out of this game, there was no severe injury to Hudler other than the blood, he came back and he's playing, and the Ducks had to play with 11 forwards the rest of the game. There may not be a suspension in this case.

Share This

Share This

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to FarkAdd to TwitterAdd to Stumble UponAdd to Reddit
Print this Story

The NHL Trade Deadline

The NHL's trade freeze before the Olympics begins Friday at 3pm et, with the trade deadline looming on Wed, Mar. 3 at 3pm et. Stay on top of all the wheeling and dealing.


TSN.ca's TradeCentre Page

Review all the trades so far

Get the deals with TSN's text alerts

Send It To Dave

Dave Hodge sounds off on all the hockey issues of the day. Click on the link below to read some of his favourite responses to the latest question.


"Will Canada win men's hockey gold in Vancouver - and if not, who will?"

StarOne Tickets

Tickets

NHL 2009-2010 Tickets

We have the best selection of NHL Tickets for every team and every location, including great seats for the Toronto Maple Leafs.
Click here to get your Hockey tickets now!

hockey pool

The Insiders Are Tweeting

Get the latest on trades, rumours and league news from TSN Hockey Insiders Bob McKenzie and Darren Dreger as it happens.


twitter.com/TSNBobMcKenzie

twitter.com/DarrenDreger


More about TSN on Twitter

Photo Galleries

Photo Gallery

Rush Hour: Images from the video shoot of Rush drummer Neil Peart's recording of The Hockey Theme. Launch Gallery