Columnist image
Frank Seravalli

TSN Senior Hockey Reporter


CHICAGO — Ottawa Senators GM Pierre Dorion insists he harbours no animosity toward Dion Phaneuf after he declined to waive his no-move clause for the expansion draft, but the Senators continue to explore options to trade the blue liner.

Phaneuf, 32, submitted a list of 12 teams to the Senators earlier this month to which he will accept a trade, as per the terms of his contract.

Dorion said “teams have been phoning” Phaneuf to inquire about his willingness to move. There has been trade interest from some of the other 19 teams that are not on Phaneuf’s list and the Senators have reached out to Phaneuf’s agents at Newport Sports Group to gauge whether he would be flexible, according to Darren Dreger.

Dorion said he hasn’t spoken to Phaneuf since their conversation earlier this month, when his decision forced the Senators to make him one of their three protected defencemen, thus exposing Marc Methot.

“I think I wanted to wait until after the draft here because teams have been phoning him,” Dorion said Saturday. “From there, we would explore all avenues and then I’ll probably reach out to him in the next week and just talk to him.”

Dorion admitted the Senators weren’t “very happy about losing Methot,” the longtime partner to Erik Karlsson. He was claimed by the Golden Knights in last week’s expansion draft. Vegas is actively trying to trade Methot, but he can’t be reacquired by the Senators until Jan. 1, 2018, according to league rules.

“It’s not the end of the world,” Dorion said. “I think the best quote I gave was ‘we didn’t lose Erik Karlsson, we lost Erik Karlsson’s partner.’ There’s a big difference.”

Dorion also said it wasn’t an easy conversation to have with Phaneuf to ask him to waive his no-move clause.

“It was a man-to-man conversation. There was no bull****,” Dorion said. “When we talked to him, I explained to him: ‘I said it’s not that you’re the fourth-best defenceman on this team, Dion. It’s we want to try to keep our top four in-tact. A big part of our success is because of our top four last year.”

The Senators advanced to the Eastern Conference final for the first time since 2007 and took the Stanley Cup champion Pittsburgh Penguins to double overtime in Game 7.

Phaneuf was acquired by Ottawa in 2016 in a surprising trade from the Toronto Maple Leafs. The Senators were one of the teams on Phaneuf’s approved trade list that time around, a list structured with the idea that the Leafs would not be dealing with a division rival, thus further limiting the number of likely destinations beyond 19.

Losing Methot and trading Phaneuf would represent major change to Ottawa’s blue line. Phaneuf put together his best season since 2014 with Cody Ceci and was even better during the Sens’ playoff run. Even if Ben Harpur and Fredrik Claesson are ready to take the next step in the NHL, that could mean a rough start to next season without further support, particularly if Karlsson misses any time after his offseason surgery to repair torn ankle ligaments.

Dorion seemed to get agitated when asked if Phaneuf would be welcomed back.

“That’s his right and I respect the right that Dion can say ‘No,’” Dorion said. “Isn’t it a good thing that someone wants to be in Ottawa? I think it’s a good thing that Dion still wants to be part of what we’re trying to build here. So I’ve got no problems with Dion.

“I’ll reach out to Dion at some point in time and I’ll just explain to him, ‘Don’t worry, you’re welcome in this room. I told him over the phone: ‘Dion, I’ll shake your hand, there’ll never be an issue ever again.’ Not that there was one, but there won’t be an issue.”


Trade Bait - June 24

Player Pos Age 2017-18 Cap Hit GP G PTS Past 2016-17 Clause
1. Matt Duchene, COL C 26 $6M 77 18 41 2 years  
2. Alex Galchenyuk, MTL LW 23   61 17 44 RFA  
3. Dion Phaneuf, OTT LD 32 $7M 81 9 30 4 years NTC
4. Marc Methot, VGK LD 32 $4.9M 68 0 12 2 years NTC
5. Marco Scandella, MIN LD 27 $4M 71 4 13 3 years  
6. Marcus Kruger, CHI C 27 $3.083M 70 5 17 2 years  
7. Tyson Barrie, COL RD 25 $5.5M 74 7 38 3 years  
8. Luca Sbisa, VGK LD 27 $3.6M 82 2 13 UFA  
9. Evander Kane, BUF LW 25 $5.25M 70 28 43 1 year  
10. Matt Dumba, MIN RD 22 $2.55M 76 11 34 1 year  
11. Ilya Kovalchuk, NJD LW 34   60 32 78 UFA  
12 Alexei Emelin, VGK LD 31 $4.1M 76 2 10 1 year NTC
13. Chris Tanev, VAN RD 27 $4.45M 53 2 10 3 years  
14. Jason Demers, FLA RD 29 $4.5M 81 9 28 4 years NTC
15. Jimmy Hayes, BOS RW 27 $2.3M 58 2 5 1 year  

Contact Frank Seravalli on Twitter: @frank_seravalli