Columnist image
Scott Cullen Analytics


Five of the past six Stanley Cups have gone to either the Chicago Blackhawks or Los Angeles Kings.

It would be easy enough to pile onto those bandwagons and force others to knock them off. While the defending-champion Blackhawks haven’t been the dominant possession team that they have been in previous years, the Kings have continued as the league’s best possession team.

Given the championship pedigree of their respective cores, it’s really difficult to go against the Blackhawks and Kings, and yet, my picks are pulling me in other directions.

How you project the playoffs to turn out always impacts the value of players in playoff pools, but especially so if you open up the field beyond the traditional favourites, and even moreso when considering the daunting matchups that those favourites face in the first round. 

Both the San Jose Sharks and St. Louis Blues have made a habit of falling short in the playoffs, which is a tough reputation to have when running into the Blackhawks, Kings and Anaheim Ducks while trying to navigate the Western Conference. It’s not as if those teams won’t be in the way again this year, but I’m being drawn (again) to the Blues, who are nearly healthy for the first time all season. 

I swore, after they lost to Minnesota last year, that I was done picking the Blues, but they sure seem to be catching a vulnerable Blackhawks team. It’s entirely possible that the Blackhawks will be able to flip the switch once the postseason begins, but their possession decline this year is a real concern. 

Ultimately, I have the Ducks taking advantage of their more favourable path -- earned with a win in Game No. 82 -- and reaching the Stanley Cup Final, where they will meet the Pittsburgh Penguins. A pair of teams that stumbled out of the gate to start the season, but have been playing as well as any over the past four months. The Penguins have a pressing issue, with goaltenders Marc-Andre Fleury and Matt Murray injured, but if Jeff Zatkoff can provide even adequate netminding off the start, the Penguins could run through the Eastern Conference. The sooner they get Evgeni Malkin back from injury, the more that they are likely to have the firepower to withstand their goaltending challenges.

Here is my breakdown for the 2016 NHL Playoffs, and I'm looking at this as a time for change, with only one of my Conference Finalists this year a repeat from last year's final four teams.

So, make your own picks and enjoy. Good luck and have fun!

For more information, please check out the Playoff Payoff, a more detailed stats breakdown, with strategy, likely line combinations and stats for notable players on each team.

The Pick: Capitals in six.
Why? Washington ran away from the rest of the Eastern Conference and have a deep and talented roster that has legitimate designs on a Stanley Cup. As well as the Flyers have played to surge into the postseason, they have more holes and will likely need Steve Mason to steal the series if they are going to knock off the Capitals. The challenge there is that while the Capitals are a middling possession team, they always have a great power play and Mason has struggled in shorthanded situations this year, so if the Flyers are going to overcome the Capitals, they will need to somehow avoid getting burned by Alex Ovechkin and company with the man advantage.

The Pick: Penguins in six.
Why? The bigger question might be ‘why not?’ The only pressing concern for the Penguins is goaltending, where Marc-Andre Fleury and Matt Murray are both injured, leaving Jeff Zatkoff to backstop one of the top teams over the past four months. Since changing coaches in December, the Penguins have been dominating puck possession and have steamrolled the opposition late in the year, winning 14 of 16, even with star centre Evgeni Malkin and young blueliner Olli Maata, among others, on the injured list. Going up against a Rangers team that is the worst possession team in the postseason – even before accounting for the loss of captain Ryan McDonagh – and that means the Blueshirts will need goaltender Henrik Lundqvist to stand on his head.

The Pick: Panthers in six.
Why? Neither team impresses as a legitimate championship contender, but the Panthers bolstered their lineup at the trade deadline and that depth should give them an edge. Florida should also hold an edge in goal, where Roberto Luongo continues to be great and, after an injury to Jaroslav Halak, the Islanders have turned to Thomas Greiss.

The Pick: Lightning in seven.
Why? If they were healthy, the Lightning would be a conceivable pick to get back to the Cup Final, but they are most definitely not healthy, missing Steven Stamkos and Anton Stralman, at the very least and that should make this a competitive series. Both teams have defensive groups that can be exposed, so Tampa Bay’s edge in goal – Ben Bishop is my pick for the Vezina this season – is enough to give them the nod.

The Pick: Ducks in six.
Why? When the Ducks started the season miserably, and couldn’t score, they found a way to win anyway, by becoming a dominant defensive team. That’s really paid off now that they are finding the net and it’s what makes Anaheim such a formidable matchup in the postseason. They have depth throughout the lineup and between young goaltenders John Gibson and Frederik Andersen, should have enough in net to go on a long playoff run. That the Ducks are really good presents a challenge for the Predators, who have assembled a quality team too, and they have more offensive upside than they have had in the past, but the question that hangs over Nashville is goaltending. Pekka Rinne had a .908 save percentage this season and that’s not nearly good enough to get the job done, but if Rinne plays well, maybe the Ducks could be stopped before they even get started.

The Pick: Sharks in six.
Why? After missing the postseason last year, both the Kings and Sharks are back and could be legitimate Cup contenders this year. So, naturally, they meet in the first round. The last time they met, in 2014, the Sharks raced to a three-games-to-none series lead, only to collapse and lose in seven games. The Kings have been the league’s dominant possession team all year, but they don’t appear to have a clear edge over the Sharks. This one’s probably close to a toss-up, with the winner having a legit chance to go to the Cup Final.

The Pick: Stars in five.
Why? The Stars have been one of the most fun teams to watch all season, with an up-tempo attacking style, and if they get Tyler Seguin back from his Achilles injury, they will have the horses to push the attack. Minnesota stumbled down the stretch, yet still reached the playoffs, but they’re also dealing with some injuries and it looks like they will need a standout performance in net from Devan Dubnyk (or, conversely, a poor performance from Dallas’ two tenders) if they are going to make this a competitive series.

The Pick: Blues in six.
Why? It would be easy to pencil in the Blackhawks to go on another playoff run, because they have embodied postseason excellence over the past six years, winning three Stanley Cups. And yet, they come into the playoffs as a mediocre possession team, lacking depth on the blueline and missing suspended star defenceman Duncan Keith for the first game. These might be hurdles that the Blackhawks can overcome, but they’re also meeting a Blues team that has fought through adversity all year long, constantly dealing with injuries to key players. Heading into the playoffs, though, the Blues are relatively healthy and have the depth (behind a game-breaker like Vladimir Tarasenko) to push play against Chicago.

Future Series Picks

Anaheim over San Jose
St. Louis over Dallas
Anaheim over St. Louis

Pittsburgh over Washington
Florida over Tampa Bay
Pittsburgh over Florida

Pittsburgh over Anaheim

Here is my list of playoff projections, obviously influenced by my team picks. If you have different picks -- and I'm sure many of you do -- do not follow my player picks to the letter; perhaps use the Playoff Payoff to find value on the teams you like best this spring.



1 Sidney Crosby Pittsburgh C 29
2 Ryan Getzlaf Anaheim C 22
3 Kris Letang Pittsburgh D 20
4 Evgeni Malkin Pittsburgh C 20
5 Corey Perry Anaheim RW 19
6 Phil Kessel Pittsburgh RW 19
7 Ryan Kesler Anaheim C 18
8 Jaromir Jagr Florida RW 16
9 Patric Hornqvist Pittsburgh RW 14
10 Jakob Silfverberg Anaheim RW 14
11 Jussi Jokinen Florida LW 14
12 Sami Vatanen Anaheim D 13
13 Chris Kunitz Pittsburgh LW 13
14 Alex Ovechkin Washington LW 12
15 Aleksander Barkov Florida C 12
16 Jamie Benn Dallas LW 12
17 Vladimir Tarasenko St. Louis RW 12
18 Nick Bonino Pittsburgh C 12
19 Carl Hagelin Pittsburgh LW 12
20 Rickard Rakell Anaheim C 12
21 Jason Spezza Dallas C 11
22 Jiri Hudler Florida LW 11
23 Tyler Seguin Dallas C 10
24 Nicklas Backstrom Washington C 10
25 Evgeny Kuznetsov Washington C 10
26 Hampus Lindholm Anaheim D 10
27 Nikita Kucherov Tampa Bay RW 10
28 Jonathan Huberdeau Florida LW 10
29 Reilly Smith Florida RW 10
30 Teddy Purcell Florida RW 10
31 Cam Fowler Anaheim D 10
32 Andrew Cogliano Anaheim LW 10
33 Matt Cullen Pittsburgh C 10
34 Paul Stastny St. Louis C 9
35 Jamie McGinn Anaheim LW 9
36 Joe Thornton San Jose C 9
37 Ondrej Palat Tampa Bay LW 9
38 Anze Kopitar Los Angeles C 8
39 Tyler Johnson Tampa Bay C 8
40 Trevor Daley Pittsburgh D 8
41 Patrick Sharp Dallas RW 8
42 Alexander Steen St. Louis LW 8
43 Joe Pavelski San Jose RW 7
44 Justin Williams Washington RW 7
45 Jaden Schwartz St. Louis LW 7
46 Ales Hemsky Dallas RW 7
47 Kevin Shattenkirk St. Louis D 7
48 Brian Campbell Florida D 7
49 Robby Fabbri St. Louis RW 7
50 David Perron Anaheim LW 7
51 Alex Pietrangelo St. Louis D 7
52 Victor Hedman Tampa Bay D 7
53 Jeff Carter Los Angeles C 7
54 Patrick Kane Chicago RW 7
55 Cody Eakin Dallas C 7
56 Alex Killorn Tampa Bay LW 7
57 Brent Burns San Jose D 7
58 John Carlson Washington D 7
59 David Backes St. Louis C 7
60 Nick Bjugstad Florida C 7
61 T.J. Oshie Washington RW 6
62 Filip Forsberg Nashville LW 6
63 Alex Goligoski Dallas D 6
64 Milan Lucic Los Angeles LW 6
65 Logan Couture San Jose C 6
66 John Klingberg Dallas D 6
67 Patrick Marleau San Jose C 6
68 Marcus Johansson Washington C 6
69 Drew Doughty Los Angeles D 6
70 Claude Giroux Philadelphia C 6
71 Tyler Toffoli Los Angeles RW 6
72 John Tavares N.Y. Islanders C 6
73 Tomas Hertl San Jose LW 6
74 Jonathan Drouin Tampa Bay LW 6
75 Jori Lehtera St. Louis C 6
76 Marian Gaborik Los Angeles LW 6
77 Aaron Ekblad Florida D 5
78 Troy Brouwer St. Louis RW 5
79 Jason Chimera Washington LW 5
80 Andre Burakovsky Washington LW 5
81 Brandon Pirri Anaheim RW 5
82 Ryan Johansen Nashville C 5
83 Colton Parayko St. Louis D 5
84 Jonathan Toews Chicago C 5
85 Zach Parise Minnesota LW 5
86 Brayden Schenn Philadelphia LW 5
87 Pavel Datsyuk Detroit C 5
88 Valtteri Filppula Tampa Bay C 5
89 Joel Ward San Jose RW 5
90 Derek Stepan N.Y. Rangers C 4
91 Wayne Simmonds Philadelphia RW 4
92 Kyle Okposo N.Y. Islanders RW 4
93 James Neal Nashville RW 4
94 Jakub Voracek Philadelphia RW 4
95 Artemi Panarin Chicago LW 4
96 Patrik Berglund St. Louis LW 4
97 Valeri Nichushkin Dallas LW 4
98 Tanner Pearson Los Angeles LW 4
99 Derick Brassard N.Y. Rangers C 4
100 Marc-Edouard Vlasic San Jose D 4
101 Mats Zuccarello N.Y. Rangers RW 4
102 Matt Niskanen Washington D 4
103 Henrik Zetterberg Detroit LW 4
104 Ryan Callahan Tampa Bay RW 4
105 Andrew Ladd Chicago LW 4
106 Dustin Brown Los Angeles RW 4
107 Kris Versteeg Los Angeles RW 4
108 Keith Yandle N.Y. Rangers D 4
109 Mike Ribeiro Nashville C 4
110 Jake Muzzin Los Angeles D 4
111 Duncan Keith Chicago D 4
112 Shea Weber Nashville D 4
113 Craig Smith Nashville RW 4
114 Marian Hossa Chicago RW 4
115 Mikko Koivu Minnesota C 4
116 Brent Seabrook Chicago D 4
117 Eric Staal N.Y. Rangers C 4
118 Jason Pominville Minnesota RW 3
119 Mikael Granlund Minnesota C 3
120 Erik Haula Minnesota C 3
121 Vladislav Namestnikov Tampa Bay C 3
122 Chris Kreider N.Y. Rangers LW 3
123 Mattias Janmark Dallas LW 3
124 Roman Josi Nashville D 3
125 Nino Niederreiter Minnesota LW 3
126 Frans Nielsen N.Y. Islanders C 3
127 Artem Anisimov Chicago C 3
128 Ryan Suter Minnesota D 3
129 Sean Couturier Philadelphia C 3
130 Anton Stralman Tampa Bay D 3
131 Vincent Lecavalier Los Angeles C 3
132 J.T. Miller N.Y. Rangers LW 3
133 Radek Faksa Dallas C 3
134 Calle Jarnkrok Nashville LW 3
135 Dylan Larkin Detroit LW 3
136 Mike Green Detroit D 3
137 Teuvo Teravainen Chicago C 3
138 Charlie Coyle Minnesota C 3
139 Tomas Tatar Detroit LW 3
140 Shayne Gostisbehere Philadelphia D 3
141 Nick Leddy N.Y. Islanders D 3
142 Kevin Hayes N.Y. Rangers LW 3
143 Joonas Donskoi San Jose RW 3
144 Dmitry Orlov Washington D 3
145 Josh Bailey N.Y. Islanders LW 3
146 Rick Nash N.Y. Rangers LW 3
147 Andrew Shaw Chicago RW 3
148 Niklas Kronwall Detroit D 3
149 Olli Maatta Pittsburgh D 3
150 Ryan Strome N.Y. Islanders RW 3
151 Jason Garrison Tampa Bay D 3
152 Gustav Nyquist Detroit RW 3
153 Justin Abdelkader Detroit RW 3
154 Mark Streit Philadelphia D 2
155 Mathew Dumba Minnesota D 2
156 Michael Raffl Philadelphia LW 2
157 Brock Nelson N.Y. Islanders LW 2
158 Ryan Ellis Nashville D 2
159 Jesper Fast N.Y. Rangers RW 2
160 Mike Fisher Nashville C 2



1 John Gibson Anaheim
2 Brian Elliott St. Louis
3 Roberto Luongo Florida
4 Braden Holtby Washington
5 Jeff Zatkoff Pittsburgh
6 Ben Bishop Tampa Bay
7 Kari Lehtonen Dallas
8 Corey Crawford Chicago
9 Martin Jones San Jose
10 Matt Murray Pittsburgh
11 Jonathan Quick Los Angeles
12 Steve Mason Philadelphia
13 Henrik Lundqvist N.Y. Rangers
14 Pekka Rinne Nashville
15 Thomas Greiss N.Y. Islanders
16 Jimmy Howard Detroit
17 Devan Dubnyk Minnesota
18 Frederik Andersen Anaheim
19 James Reimer San Jose
20 Marc-Andre Fleury Pittsburgh
21 Petr Mrazek Detroit
22 Antti Niemi Dallas


Scott Cullen can be reached at