GOAT of GOATs

GOAT of GOATS: Wilson vs. MPP

Published: 

There are GOATs and then there is the GOAT of GOATs. TSN brings you GOAT of GOATs presented by Desjardins Business. Sixteen legendary athletes – eight men and eight women – square off in a bracket to determine who is the best of the best, the greatest of the greatest.

TSN personalities will present the case for each athlete, but it’s up to you to have your say. Viewers will vote on each matchup until two competitors are sent to the finals, with a winner crowned on each side of the bracket. Voting will consist of a split between viewers and TSN staff.

Today’s matchup: A’ja Wilson versus Marie-Philip Poulin

--

A'ja Wilson (Lindsey Wasson)

A’ja Wilson

It’s not often that an athlete still very much in here prime has already entered the conversation to be the best player a sport has ever seen, but A’ja Wilson is hardly just any other athlete.

At only 30 years old, Wilson’s body of work through nine WNBA seasons has already made her a lock for enshrinement in Springfield. The Columbia, SC native is a dominant a force as the league has seen in three decades. Her consistency has established Wilson as the benchmark in the modern game.

The top high-school prospect in the country in 2014, Wilson had her pick of schools to attend. She opted to stay in Columbia and enrolled in South Carolina to play under Dawn Staley. By the time Wilson arrived at the Gamecocks, Staley’s sea change at the program was in full effect.

After years of being a complete afterthought in the SEC, South Carolina had begun to emerge as a conference power with Staley at the helm. Staley and Wilson were about to make history.

In 2017, the Gamecocks capped off regular-season and SEC tournament titles with the program’s first-ever National Championship. In the final against Mississippi State, Wilson scored 24 points and added 10 boards in the 67-55 win. She was named March Madness’s Most Outstanding Player.

Coming off of winning the Naismith College Player of the Year and John R. Wooden Awards, It would come as no surprise that Wilson would be selected with the first-overall pick of the 2018 WNBA Draft by the Las Vegas Aces. While many college standouts struggle in their first pro seasons, Wilson did not. Averaging 20.7 points and 8.0 rebounds a night, Wilson claimed her first All-Star nod and was named WNBA Rookie of the Year.

Trips to the All-Star Game became commonplace for Wilson as the Aces began to turn their fortunes around. After a four-year absence, the team returned to the playoffs in her second season. In Year 3, the pandemic-shortened 2020 season, Wilson won her first Most Valuable Player Award, securing 43 of 47 first-place votes.

After years of not being able to get over the hump, the Aces fired head coach Bill Laimbeer following the 2021 season. In his place came former franchise great and longtime San Antonio Spurs assistant coach Becky Hammon. The partnership between Hammon and Wilson was transformative.

In the first four years under Hammon, the Aces would win three WNBA titles. In all three of those seasons, Wilson would claim WNBA MVP honours. In both 2023 and 2025, she would also win WNBA Finals MVP. Wilson’s 2024 MVP was unanimous and her win in 2025 made her the first player in league history to win four MVPs. In 2022, 2023 and 2025, Wilson would add Defensive Player of the Year honours to her ever-growing trophy haul.

Wilson added to her legacy in 2026. For a season in which she averaged 26.2 points, 9.4 boards and a career-high 3.2 assists, Wilson earned a fifth MVP nod. In doing so, she joined Wayne Gretzky, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Peyton Manning, Gordie Howe, Bill Russell, Michael Jordan and Barry Bonds as the only players to have won five or more MVP awards in North American sports history.

Representing the United States on several occasions, Wilson’s excellence translated to the international game. After claiming several honours at the youth level, Wilson made her senior debut at the 2018 FIBA World Cup in a gold-medal winning effort in Spain. Her next trip to the World Cup four years later saw Wilson earn not only another gold medal, but individual hardware as tournament MVP at Australia 2022.

It was a similar story at the Olympics. She and the United States won a gold medal in her Olympics debut at Tokyo 2020. It was a repeat performance at Paris 2024. This time, though, she would lead Team USA in points, rebounds, steals, blocks, field goals made en route to an MVP nod. Wilson also had a game-high 21 points and 13 boards in the gold-medal game, a 67-66 nail-biter over France.

Heading into her 10th campaign next year, Wilson needs just 12 points to pass Sue Bird on the all-time list and enter the top 10. Her 22.1 points per game are the most in league history. Wilson’s 9.34 boards per night is the fourth-highest average, as are her 2.0 blocks per game.

Making history has been Wilson’s calling card and she’s not done yet.

--

Marie-Philip Poulin

Marie-Philip Poulin

There’s no such thing as a clutch gene. It simply does not exist. And yet for some athletes, the ability to rise to the occasion seems so innate that you can’t help but wonder if it’s naturally derived.

Marie-Philip Poulin is one such athlete. With an ostensibly preternatural ability to be in the right spot, to make the right decision and to come up when needed most, MPP has already established herself among the finest hockey players the country has ever produced. Already staking claim to the mantle of best women’s hockey player ever, Poulin’s case could be undeniable by the time she hangs up her skates.

A native of Quebec City, Poulin made her senior debut for Canada in 2009 at the IIHF Women’s World Championship in Finland at the age of 17. The call-up came after Poulin ran roughshod on the record books at the U-18 level. In only 17 games, she racked up a program record 31 points.

Poulin quickly proved she wasn’t out of her depths. She scored two goals and added three assists in five games at the tournament. Her first worlds concluded with a silver medal.

Her first taste of gold came at the 2010 Vancouver Olympics. It would be at this tournament where Poulin started her remarkable legacy of timely play. After notching three goals and three assists during Canada’s undefeated group stage, she picked up an assist in Canada’s victory over Finland in the semis.

In the final against the rival United States, Poulin took the spotlight. With just over six minutes to play in the first period, Poulin took a feed from Jennifer Botterill inside the face-off circle to the right of Molly Schaus and beat the American goaltender blocker-side with a wrister to make it 1-0. Less than three minutes later, she won a draw in the attacking zone and picked up Meghan Agosta’s rebound to beat Schaus again to make it 2-0.

That was all the offence Canada would need to claim the gold medal with a 2-0 victory. Poulin was named to the team of the tournament. It was her first gold medal-winning goal, but it wouldn’t be her last.

At the 2014 Sochi Olympics, Poulin’s performance late was even more impressive. After a quiet (by her standards) group stage and semis in which she notched three points, Poulin made the gold medal game hers yet again. She was inevitable.

A goal by Alex Carpenter just over two minutes into the third period gave the U.S. a 2-0 lead and Canada was scrambling. With the clock ticking down, Brianne Jenner pulled Canada within one with a fluke goal that was deflected past Jessie Vetter with just over three minutes remaining in regulation. Minutes later, Poulin would force overtime. With Canada’s net empty, Rebecca Johnston centred the puck from behind the net where Poulin beat Vetter to tie it at 2-2 with 54 seconds remaining.

Poulin’s legend grew in the extra frame. With under eight minutes to play in overtime and Catherine Ward and Jocelyne Lamoureux both already in the box, Hilary Knight hauled down Hayley Wickenheiser on a partial breakaway and Canada would go to a 4-on-3 power-play. As the U.S. frantically defended, Laura Fortino set up Poulin to rifle home her second gold medal-winning goal on the PP.

One gold medal-winning goal would be the hallmark of most careers. A second would be the stuff of legend. A third? That’s just what Poulin, who became senior team captain in 2015, does.

As Canada and the U.S. met in yet another gold-medal game, Poulin won a draw with a little under eight minutes left in the first period. Claire Thompson threw puck to the front of the net where it was redirected by Sarah Nurse to make it 1-0. With five minutes left in the period, sloppy play from the U.S. saw Poulin steal a puck down low on the half-boards, turn around and fool Alex Cavallini with a wrister to make it 2-0.

Midway through the second Canada would ice the game. A heads-up pass from Erin Ambrose off the glass sprung Nurse into the U.S. zone with one defender back. Nurse spotted the arrival of the trailing Jenner whose hard shot was saved well by Cavallini, but the rebound fell into the path of Poulin, who slotted home her second of the game to make it 3-0.

After third-period goals from Knight and Amanda Kessel, Canada would hold on for the 3-2 win for Poulin’s third gold medal-winning goal. Finishing the tournament with six goals and 11 assists, Poulin trailed only Nurse for the Olympics scoring lead.

While Canada did not win gold at Milano Cortina 2026, Poulin further buttressed her incredible stat line. Canada earned a silver medal, losing in overtime to the United States in the gold-medal game. But after scoring twice in Canada’s 2-1 win over Switzerland, Poulin became the first player in history with 20 Olympic goals.

Though Poulin’s legend has been largely built on her international play, it would be remiss to not speak of her club career. A perennial winner, she has claimed honours everywhere she’s played. In the now-defunct Canadian Women’s Hockey League, Poulin led the league in scoring on three occasions, claiming three Angela James Trophies, and won three Jayna Hefford Trophies as the most valuable player. Her Montreal Stars/Les Canadiennes de Montreal won the the Clarkson Cup in 2009 and 2017.

Her exploits have continued into the Professional Women’s Hockey League. Over three seasons with the Montreal Victoire, Poulin has been twice named a First Team All-Star. In 2025, she claimed a trifecta of awards, winning Top Goal Scorer, Forward of the Year and the Billie Jean King MVP. With 67 points in 70 career games, Poulin is the league’s all-time leading scorer. She also added an Ilana Kloss Playoff MVP in 2026 as the Victoire won their first Walter Cup.

Now 35, Poulin’s assault on history isn’t over. Already Canada’s leading scorer of all-time at the tournament, she trails the retiring Knight by 44 points for most in worlds history. The Olympics goals leader, her 39 points are second-most all-time behind Wickenheiser’s 51.

Bet against more greatness from Poulin at your own peril.