EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. -- The traditional numbers say one thing on New York Giants edge rusher Abdul Carter. The advanced metrics say another. It has put Carter under the microscope about whether he’s actually doing enough with the immense talent at his disposal.
Carter, the No. 3 overall pick out of Penn State in the 2025 NFL draft, has two sacks, three tackles for loss and eight quarterback hits this season. That ranks him tied for 99th, 156th and tied for 55th in those categories, respectively. Not exactly impressive.
“At the end of the day, I’ve got to do more, especially to get more sacks, get more production,” Carter said. “But at the same time, as long as my main goal is focusing on winning.”
On the surface, the lack of sacks and hard numbers seems insufficient. But dig deeper and a different story gets revealed. Carter has a 29.0% pass rush win rate, 16 forced incompletions, two interceptions created and 17 quick pressures (pressures in under 2.5 seconds). That ranks him second, first, tied for sixth and tied for eighth in those categories, respectively.
The advanced metrics depict a player making a significant impact, much like the coaches’ tape.
“I don’t go through all those stats and try to dig out every little metric on every guy. We get a general accounting of it,” coach John Harbaugh said. “I definitely look at the team stats. But I’m looking at the tape. Myself, I’m grading every single guy. Plus, every coach is grading their position all the time. And he’s grading out really well on my sheet, I can tell you that, and the coaches’ sheet. He’s a disruptive guy. I promise you they’re accounting for him. And the sacks are just going to come.”
Carter is getting double-teamed on a team-high 41% of opposing quarterback dropbacks. That indicates a level of respect.
But somewhere there seems to be a disconnect between the pressures/disruptive plays and sacks.
“I’m trying to figure that out,” Carter said.
It doesn’t help that opposing quarterbacks are getting the ball out in 2.70 seconds before the pass. Only the Tampa Bay Buccaneers have seen quarterbacks get the ball out quicker. The Giants also aren’t known to have one of the better interior pass rushing groups.So there aren’t a lot of freebies for Carter and the edge rushing group. Fellow outside linebacker Kayvon Thibodeaux is still looking for his first sack of the season.
The sacks are the most glaring omission from Carter’s résumé. That’s where pass rushers make their name and money. Carter has just six sacks in 26 games over his first two seasons.
It’s not lost on the 23-year-old edge rusher. He’s seen the critiques. Just the other day, he warned on social media that he’s heard the noise and to watch out Sunday against the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Clearly, he’s noticed the critics. And he’s not backing down from the critiques.
“I hear everything,” Carter told ESPN. “This is New York. This is not somewhere you can hide from the noise or block it out. So I embrace everything and I definitely use it as motivation.”
It’s commendable that Carter is not backing down from the challenge. That says something about his confidence, which appears to be undented. Carter, who tried to wear Lawrence Taylor’s No. 56 upon his arrival in New York, told NJ.com this week he’s still “going to be the greatest ever.”
He knows that getting sacks is a big part of making that happen.
“I think it should be on my mind,” Carter said of getting the quarterback on the ground.
He hasn’t done it enough his first two seasons. New York Jets rookie David Bailey has more sacks (7.5) in one fewer year. Rookie inside linebacker Arvell Reese leads the Giants with 4.5 sacks this season.
Carter still needs more fine-tuning to his game to facilitate finishing plays. He’s getting the quick pressures, but quarterbacks are getting the ball out quickly as a result. When he’s not getting those immediate pressures, that is when it appears to be breaking down. There is no counter that is leading to sacks.
It doesn’t seem to worry the Giants much.
“I believe the sacks will come,” Harbaugh said. “There is no one answer. They’re going to happen. Just go play football.”
Former Giants linebacker and current radio host Carl Banks said recently on his podcast that it could benefit Carter if the Giants used him in games (twists, stunts and moving spots) to potentially get free runs at the quarterback. There haven’t been many of those for Carter over the first nine games of this season.
The onus is on defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson. His defenses have relied heavily on blitzes and Carter for most of their pressure this season. The Giants have blitzed at a 45.3% rate since Week 4, the second highest of any team.
“We’re trying to put [Carter] in positions for him to get some touches on the quarterback, but he’s doing everything he’s supposed to do,” Wilson said. “In the run game, he’s been excellent. He’s holding force. The ball isn’t circling outside of him. So, I love where he’s at. I just wish the production was a little bit more for him right now because he deserves it, especially the work that he’s putting in.”
While Carter’s coaches are singing his praises, he knows it’s going to take more to get the doubters on board. Two sacks in nine games isn’t going to do it. Four sacks for the second straight season isn’t going to impress any All-Pro or Pro Bowl voters.
The lack of traditional stats is notable. Even to Carter.
“It’s definitely frustrating,” he said. “But at the end of the day, it’s not going to blind me from the main goal. And the main goal is to always going to be to win. But at the same time, I can always have that extra chip on my shoulder. I have to do more. I have to get more production. But I’m not going to chase. I’m not going to do something outside my job.
“As long as I’m doing everything to contribute to winning, I’ll be all right. We just got to win. That’s all.”