Betting
nhlOpens in new window
Toronto Maple LeafsOpens in new window

How will Maple Leafs respond after winless homestand?

Updated: 

Published: 

The Toronto Maple Leafs changed a lot in the offseason.

New management, a new head coach, a new goaltender, and several new faces brought in to fill out their roster.

There were plenty of differences to highlight on paper.

Unfortunately, now 22 games into the 2026-27 season, it’s the results that haven’t changed.

The Maple Leafs have lost eight of their last nine games in regulation, including six straight on home ice, to fall to the bottom of the Atlantic Division standings.

It’s the first time in franchise history that Toronto has finished a six-game homestand without a single point.

General manager John Chayka called it, “unacceptable”.

“Guys gotta look in the mirror and just ask a little bit more of themselves and take on a little bit more,” captain Auston Matthews told reporters last week.

As the frustration continues to build, Leafs Nation is left asking the same questions it did in the offseason.

What must be done for Toronto to become a contender?

As ugly as things have looked over the last two weeks, my opinion of the Maple Leafs hasn’t changed after their six-game slide.

Allow me to explain why in this Morning Coffee column for Tuesday November 17th, 2026.

How Will Maple Leafs Respond After Winless Homestand?

When the Maple Leafs hired Chayka as GM in June, there was a clear mandate to reshape a roster that many felt had underachieved.

Chayka hired Jim Hiller as head coach and went to work with several aggressive moves in both free agency and the trade market.

He signed veteran Sergei Bobrovsky to a three-year, $21 million deal to upgrade his goaltending.

He acquired veterans Darren Raddysh and Nick Paul from the Tampa Bay Lightning, then signed Colton Sissons, Jack Roslovic, and Brandon Duhaime as free agents.

The Maple Leafs won the NHL Draft Lottery and the chance to select Gavin McKenna first overall.

Right before the season, Chayka traded Matthew Knies to the Columbus Blue Jackets in a deal that landed Toronto Kirill Marchenko, Miles Wood, and Elvin Merzlikins.

Of course, anybody paying attention understood that it would take time for the Maple Leafs to develop a high level of chemistry and cohesion after sweeping changes.

Unfortunately, in this market, patience isn’t an option.

Marchenko has been sidelined since late October, Sissons recently joined him on the injured reserve, and Morgan Rielly is day-to-day with a lower-body injury.

McKenna is an 18-year-old rookie in his first NHL season.

Raddysh has played a career-high 24 minutes per game.

John Tavares missed nearly a month with a lower-body injury, but the Maple Leafs weathered the storm with an 8-6-2 record through 16 games.

Unfortunately, there wasn’t much they could do to avoid the perfect storm that hit in November.

As the injuries piled up, Toronto returned home to face six straight legitimate playoff contenders.

The Colorado Avalanche, Minnesota Wild, Edmonton Oilers, New Jersey Devils, and the Utah Mammoth are all among the top 10 choices to win the Stanley Cup at FanDuel.

The Montreal Canadiens probably should be with rookie goaltender Jacob Fowler putting up Vezina Trophy-calibre numbers in 13 starts this season.

The Maple Leafs were the underdog at FanDuel in all six of those regulation losses, including +130 or longer against the Devils, Avalanche, and the Wild.

Remember, after sweeping offseason changes, Toronto entered the season as basically a coin toss to make the playoffs at -118 odds at FanDuel.

That was with a healthy Marchenko, Rielly, and Sissons.

With three key players sidelined and others battling nagging injuries, is it really shocking that the Maple Leafs couldn’t pick up a win during the six-game homestand?

It’s not like Toronto lost a game it was expected to win.

Sure, it’s glaring that they didn’t secure a single point, but it isn’t like I was surprised by any specific loss during their six-game slide.

The Maple Leafs odds to make the playoffs have ballooned from -118 to +450 at FanDuel.

The current number gives them an 18.2 per cent implied chance to reach the postseason.

It doesn’t help that Toronto plays in the loaded Atlantic Division, which could very well feature five playoff teams.

It also doesn’t help that an organization with a new GM, new head coach, and several new players had to deal with key injuries during the toughest stretch of their schedule, even if we’re somehow convinced they have a distinct advantage when they play on home ice.

Chayka was tasked with building around a core that features Matthews and William Nylander, and the early results weren’t particularly terrible despite an obvious lack of chemistry to start the season.

https://x.com/TSN_Sports/status/2118769889011695881

Matthews has led Toronto with 12 goals and 29 points in 22 games, with a 1.32 points per game that is much better than his .88 points per game last season.

Nylander and Marchenko have both averaged exactly a point per game pace, while Roslovic has produced 20 points in 21 games.

The one obvious lingering issue for the Maple Leafs remains their goaltending situation, with Bobrovsky posting a miserable .881 save percentage in 13 games.

Anthony Stolarz is 5-4-0 with a .906 save percentage.

With Bobrovsky in the first of a three-year deal that pays him $7 million per season, Toronto can’t afford for him to provide anything less than league average goaltending.

Bobrovsky has allowed three or more goals in all but one start this season and with the Maple Leafs in a free fall, they’ll need better goaltending to get back on track.

Chayka has preached patience with the 38-year-old veteran, but time isn’t a luxury that this team has.

In case you missed it, I loved this clip from Jeff O’Neil on the topic of Toronto’s upcoming schedule.

While he’s right about the potential mindset of their upcoming opponents, it’s certainly noteworthy how difficult their schedule has been the last two weeks.

The Maple Leafs visit the Chicago Blackhawks tonight.

It’s the first time they’ll be the betting favourite in any game since a 4-2 win over the Vancouver Canucks on October 31st.

Toronto was -192 to beat Vancouver on Halloween night.

The Buds are -154 to beat Chicago tonight at FanDuel.

After losing six straight to legitimate Stanley Cup contenders, Toronto’s next four games are against opponents that are +176 or longer to make the playoffs.

Plus, they could have Rielly back in the lineup tonight.

The Maple Leafs made sweeping changes in the offseason, and I’m not willing to write them off until we see the full product over a larger sample size.

Then again, I bet on Toronto to miss the playoffs at -102, and there is no guarantee that they can overcome a long list of injuries and turn things around in a deep Atlantic Division.

For now, their focus is on overcoming adversity and finding a way to get their season back on track.

A win in Chicago tonight is an important first step.

I’ll lock in a play on the Maple Leafs to beat the Blackhawks.

Let’s see how they respond tonight.

Have a great day, everyone!