Hamilton Tiger-Cats quarterback Bo Levi Mitchell was a spectator for the 113th Grey Cup on Sunday between the Edmonton Elks and Montreal Alouettes.
After a season lost to injury, the veteran pivot - who described his main feeling while watching the game as “jealous” - is raring to get back on the field next season.
Mitchell joined First Up on TSN1050 on Monday morning to discuss his reflections on the Grey Cup, his expectations for next year and the quarterback landscape in the CFL.
“I’m just jealous,” Mitchell said, laughing, when asked how he felt watching quarterback Cody Fajardo and the Elks knock off the Alouettes 37-30 to clinch the title. “Watching the game, you just want to be there. As a player, as a competitor, you want to be in that game, you want to be in that scenario at all times. Having the ball in your hand to win the game is what you dream of as a kid and the reason you play the game.”
The 36-year-old Mitchell is a veteran of 14 CFL seasons, with two Grey Cup titles and two Most Outstanding Player awards to his name. After two of the best seasons of his storied career in 2024 and 2025, Mitchell’s 2026 campaign was cut short by a severe left ankle injury suffered in just his fourth game.
Mitchell told the First Up crew that he was working to return to the Tiger-Cats lineup this season, and had targeted the “second-to-last, third-to-last game of the season for the push to the playoffs” as a potential spot for a return. With the Tiger-Cats eliminated from the playoffs with three games left on the calendar, the return was deemed an unnecessary risk.
“Obviously with the way the season played out, our win-loss record, getting knocked out of the playoffs right before that happened, we decided not to push it at that point,” Mitchell said. “But I was definitely to the point where... I wouldn’t have been 100 per cent, but I could have gone in there, played, been out there and done my thing.”
Mitchell now views the way the season played out - no return to action, an early off-season with the team missing the playoffs - as a positive for his outlook for next year.
“I think getting it going in the off-season with the amount of work that [the support staff] put into me through [since I got hurt] definitely got me ready for this off-season. Now we get to start the off-season the day after the Grey Cup, rather than waiting until January 1, you know. Get a little bit of a head start - not for the reason you want to, getting knocked out - but it could be a blessing in disguise.”
Fajardo, who was named the Grey Cup MVP after accounting for four touchdowns on Sunday, has already indicated his intent to retire - much to his teammates’ chagrin.
He is one of a list of veteran quarterbacks whose teams will be waiting on a potential retirement decision this off-season, including Zach Collaros of the Winnipeg Blue Bombers and Trevor Harris of the Saskatchewan Roughriders. Some wondered after the injury whether Mitchell may also be included in that list.
“You talk about my status of coming back and whatnot ... something that needs to be talked about is the fact that the quarterback landscape in the CFL can change very quickly and very drastically over the next little bit,” Mitchell said. “You look at Fajardo winning a Grey Cup as he walks off into the sunset, Collaros and Harris both mulling their futures of whether or not they want to keep playing, coaching, moving on.”
Collaros struggled with injuries at age 38 this season, while Mitchell is convinced Harris has a future in coaching and wondered whether he may take the first step down that path this off-season.
“Then you got guys like [Montreal Alouettes QB and reigning MOP] Davis [Alexander] - does the NFL come calling? How much does the shoulder injury [he apparently suffered during the Grey Cup] affect that? How much does the landscape of the quarterback market, with [Toronto Argonauts QB] Chad Kelly getting paid $1 million a year, change the decision? The NFL’s undrafted free agent salary is $970,000 U.S. for three years, [does one] create legend status in the CFL, [or does one] go down there and attempt the NFL?
“Quickly the quarterback landscape can change in a sense of we’ve been talking the past couple of years about how the quarterback play has improved and [been at the forefront of] the offence that has been created over the past couple of years. It’s interesting to think of some of the legends we could lose here over the next little bit.”