Carter Esler has heard it all his life.
At five-foot-10, the Spokane Chiefs’ star goaltender has repeatedly been told he’s too small to succeed at the position. But Esler, who turns 18 on Nov. 28, isn’t buying it.
“I’ve always been told my whole life that I’m not tall enough, too small to play or be successful,” he said.
“I just have a chip on my shoulder to prove everyone wrong who doesn’t think I can do it.”
Esler leads the Western Hockey League with a 1.76 goals-against average and ranks third with a .931 save percentage. He has nine wins and a shootout loss in 10 starts for the league-leading Chiefs and was named WHL goaltender of the month for September and October.
The Okotoks, Alta., native led the WHL with five shutouts last season, his first as a full-time starter. He posted a 2.80 goals-against average and a .903 save percentage.
Yet when NHL Central Scouting released its preliminary players to watch list for 2027 draft-eligible players, Esler was nowhere to be found.
Esler said he tries not to “pay much attention to the politics stuff surrounding us.”
“He understands he can only control what you can control, and one thing with Carter, he’s very strong mentally,” Chiefs head coach Brad Lauer said. “He doesn’t let the little things bother him too much.
“I’m sure he’s not overall happy to see his name not on there, but it’s also motivation for him to keep doing what he’s doing. And I think that’s the type that drives a guy like Carter; it’s those guys that doubt him.”
Of the 54 goaltenders on NHL Central Scouting’s preliminary watch list, 38 are listed at six-foot-two or taller. Only three are under six feet, all of them European: Russia’s Sergei Sokolkin (five-foot-ten), Finland’s Patrik Joensuu (five-foot-ten and three-quarters) and Latvia’s Iļja Ņikitins (five-foot-11 and a quarter).
Sportsnet NHL draft analyst Sam Cosentino said most NHL teams won’t even consider goalies under six-foot-two. He pointed to several goalies under that height who enjoyed major success in the Canadian Hockey League but took years to become NHL backups, if they made it to the league at all.
Calgary’s Dustin Wolf and Edmonton’s Devon Levi are both six-foot goaltenders who were drafted in the seventh round and spent parts of several seasons in the American Hockey League. Wolf played at least 50 games in each of the past two seasons for the Flames, while Levi has won 10 of his first 11 games with the Oilers this season.
Cosentino said their success has done little to change how NHL teams scout smaller goaltenders.
“Go back 15 years when we were talking about the small defencemen. The idea was that if you took a smaller player, that they might be a little bit more athletically gifted, whereas now that’s not the case,” Cosentino said. “You’re finding all these players that are bigger, taller, that are equally as gifted athletically as anyone who is a smaller player.
“So then at that point, you’re always going to lean towards the size as opposed to the smaller player. So that’s just the unfortunate reality that I’ve seen in the scouting world.”
Lauer understands why NHL scouts value size. For him, though, it comes down to who’s best at stopping pucks.
“I think sometimes we tend to not give those smaller goalies those opportunities,” he said. “... I just think right now to put those labels on guys like that, it’s tough. But I think Carter’s doing a good job for himself to raise awareness for his game.”
As for Esler, he plans to continue to focus on his game.
“Just proving to those people who make those lists that they’re missing out,” he said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 19, 2026.
Abdulhamid Ibrahim, The Canadian Press
