| 2017 | Peterborough Lakers | Shawn Evans |
| 2016 | Six Nations Chiefs | Dan Dawson |
| 2015 | Victoria Shamrocks | Corey Small |
| 2014 | Six Nations Chiefs | Brandon Miller |
| 2013 | Six Nations Chiefs | Cody Jamieson |
| 2012 | Peterborough Lakers | Mike Thompson |
| 2011 | Brampton Excelsiors | Anthony Cosmo |
| 2010 | Peterborough Lakers | Shawn Evans |
| 2009 | Brampton Excelsiors | Shawn Williams |
| 2008 | Brampton Excelsiors | Anthony Cosmo |
| 2007 | Peterborough Lakers | John Grant Jr. |
| 2006 | Peterborough Lakers | Dan Carey |
| 2005 | Victoria Shamrocks | Anthony Cosmo |
| 2004 | Peterborough Lakers | John Grant Jr. |
| 2003 | Victoria Shamrocks | Andy Turner |
| 2002 | Brampton Excelsiors | Josh Sanderson |
| 2001 | Coquitlam Adanacs | Andy Ogilvie |
| 2000 | Brooklin Redmen | Nick Trudeau |
| 1999 | Victoria Shamrocks | Paul Gait and Gary Gait |
| 1998 | Brampton Excelsiors | Pat O'Toole |
| 1997 | Victoria Shamrocks | Gary Gait |
| 1996 | Six Nations Chiefs | John Tavares |
| 1995 | Six Nations Chiefs | Paul Gait |
| 1994 | Six Nations Chiefs | Darris Kilgour |
| 1993 | Brampton Excelsiors | John Tavares |
| 1992 | Brampton Excelsiors | John Tavares |
| 1991 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Geordie Dean |
| 1990 | Brooklin Redmen | Paul Gait |
| 1989 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Ben Hieltjes |
| 1988 | Brooklin Redmen | Bill Thomas |
| 1987 | Brooklin Redmen | Eric Cowieson |
| 1986 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Geordie Dean |
| 1985 | Brooklin Redmen | Wayne Colley |
| 1984 | Peterborough Lakers | John Grant |
| 1983 | Victoria Payless | John Crowther |
| 1982 | Peterborough Lakers | Jim Wasson |
| 1981 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Wayne Goss |
| 1980 | Brampton Excelsiors | Barry Maruk |
| 1979 | Victoria Shamrocks | Kevin Alexander |
| 1978 | Peterborough Red Oaks | Tim Barrie |
| 1977 | Vancouver Burrards | Doug Hayes and Mike Smith |
| 1976 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Dave Durante |
| 1975 | Vancouver Burrards | Ron Pinder |
| 1974 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Ken Winzoski |
| 1973 | Peterborough Lakers | Pat Baker |
| 1972 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Paul Parnell |
| 1971 | Brantford Warriors | Bob McCready |
| 1970 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Paul Parnell |
| 1969 | Brooklin Redmen | Bill Squires |
| 1968 | Brooklin Redmen | John Cervi and Joe Timchishem |
| 1967 | Vancouver Carlings | John Davis |
| 1966 | Peterborough Lakers | John Davis |
| 1965 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Les Norman |
| 1964 | Vancouver Carlings | Bob Allen |
| 1963 | Vancouver Carlings | Gordon Gimple |
| 1962 | New Westminster O'Keefes | Jack Bionda |
| 1961 | Vancouver Burrards | Bill Barbour |
| 1960 | Port Credit Sailors | Dave Russell |
| 1959 | New Westminster O'Keefes | Jack Bionda |
| 1958 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | Norm McKay |
| 1957 | Victoria Shamrocks | Jack Northrup |
| 1956 | Nanaimo Timbermen | Derry Davies |
| 1955 | Victoria Shamrocks | Geordie Johnson |
| 1954 | Peterborough Timbermen | Lloyd Wooton |
| 1953 | Peterborough Timbermen | Ross Powless |
| 1952 | Peterborough Timbermen | Lou Nickle |
| 1951 | Peterborough Timbermen | Lloyd Wooton |
| 1950 | Owen Sound Crescents | Lloyd Wooton |
| 1949 | Vancouver Burrards | Don Matheson |
| 1948 | Hamilton Tigers | Doug Favelle |
| 1947 | New Westminster Adanacs | Bob Lee |
| 1946 | St. Catharines Athletics | Doug Favelle |
| 1945 | Vancouver Burrards | Frank Lee |
| 1944 | St. Catharines Athletics | Ike Hildebrand |
| 1943 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | B. Wilkes |
| 1942 | Mimico/Brampton Combines | Bert Large |
| 1941 | St. Catharines Athletics | Blackie Black |
| 1940 | St. Catharines Athletics | |
| 1939 | New Westminster Adanacs | |
| 1938 | St. Catharines Athletics | |
| 1937 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1936 | Orillia Terriers | |
| 1935 | Orillia Terriers | |
| 1934 | Orillia Terriers | |
| 1933 | Hamilton Tigers | |
| 1932 | Mimico Mountaineers | |
| 1931 | Brampton Excelsiors | |
| 1930 | Brampton Excelsiors | |
| 1929 | Oshawa Generals | |
| 1928 | Ottawa Emmets | |
| 1927 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1926 | Weston Westonmen | |
| 1925 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1924 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1923 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1922 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1921 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1920 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1919 | Vancouver Foundation Club | |
| 1918 | Vancouver Coughlans | |
| 1917 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1916 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1915 | New Westminster Salmonbellies | |
| 1914 | Vancouver Athletic Club | |
| 1913 | Vancouver Athletic Club | |
| 1912 | Vancouver Athletic Club | |
| 1911 | Vancouver Athletic Club | |
| 1910 | Toronto Young Torontos | |
