MLB
Toronto Blue JaysOpens in new window
Ketel MarteOpens in new window
Brandon LoweOpens in new window
Jazz Chisholm Jr.Opens in new window
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.Opens in new window

Blue Jays must prove they can spend wisely this off-season

Published: 

The Toronto Blue Jays have a significant problem to solve this off-season: they don’t score enough runs.

After reaching Game 7 of the World Series in 2025, the Blue Jays finished last in baseball in runs scored and home runs in 2026. That’s a remarkable offensive collapse for a team with championship aspirations and one of baseball’s highest payrolls.

Ross Atkins and Mark Shapiro have acknowledged the need for more offence. The question is how they acquire it, especially with the collective bargaining agreement expiring Dec. 1 and a potential lockout looming.

If I was running the Blue Jays, I’d be looking for players who consistently impact the baseball. They need more power, better on-base percentage and hitters who can change a game with one swing.

But Toronto already has substantial financial commitments on the books, including Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s $500 million contract and Anthony Santander’s remaining salary. Adding another expensive player requires evaluating not only what he can contribute in 2027, but what that contract might look like three or four years from now.

There are options available in free agency and through trades. None of them come without risk.

Free agent targets

Chicago Cubs' Seiya Suzuki follows the flight of his grand slam off Colorado Rockies starting pitcher Ryan Feltner in the fourth inning of a baseball game Thursday, June 11, 2026, in Denver. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski) Chicago Cubs' Seiya Suzuki follows the flight of his grand slam off Colorado Rockies starting pitcher Ryan Feltner in the fourth inning of a baseball game Thursday, June 11, 2026, in Denver. (AP Photo/David Zalubowski) (David Zalubowski)

Seiya Suzuki, outfielder

Suzuki, who spent the past four seasons with the Chicago Cubs, would be at the top of my list.

He’s been one of baseball’s more consistent offensive performers since arriving from Japan for the 2022 season. He has a career 128 OPS+.

The Blue Jays need a middle-of-the-order bat who can protect Guerrero and provide more consistent run production. Suzuki can be that guy.

He also fills an outfield need, He is not a great defender, just average, but the Jays must be willing to give up some defence to add some offence.

Suzuki will play at 32 years old next season. I’d only be comfortable with a three- or four-year contract, but that may get a deal done.

Toronto needs production now, and Suzuki represents one of the better combinations of offensive ability and manageable financial risk.

Brandon Lowe, second baseman

Lowe is an interesting option because he provides the left-handed power Toronto desperately needs. There are reports that the Jays have had some conversations with his representative.

Lowe hit 35 home runs for the Pittsburgh Pirates in 2026 and has demonstrated the ability to be a legitimate middle-of-the-order threat.

Lowe is an excellent fit from a purely offensive standpoint. But I have significant concerns about his health, particularly his history of back problems. Lowe missed considerable time in 2022 with a stress reaction in his lower back and experienced additional back inflammation in 2023. I’d also be concerned about how his back would respond to playing 81 home games on the artificial turf at Rogers Centre.

Luis Arraez, second baseman

Arraez is a fascinating option because he offers something completely different from the other available hitters.

He doesn’t solve Toronto’s power problem. In fact, he provides very little home-run production.

But the guy can flat-out hit.

Arraez, who split last season between the Phillies and Giants, is a three-time batting champion who has demonstrated an extraordinary ability to put the ball in play. He rarely strikes out, consistently makes contact and can cause pitcher fits.

He hit .310 in 2026, and his offensive approach would provide a different dimension to Toronto’s lineup.

The concerns involve his limited power, modest walk totals and defensive limitations, although his defensive numbers were much improved in 2026. If the Jays go this route, they will need to add a run producer to go along with Arraez.

Jazz Chisholm Jr., infielder

Chisholm offers another offensive dimension.

He brings power, speed and athleticism. He’s capable of hitting the ball out of the ballpark, stealing bases and creating scoring opportunities without relying exclusively on home runs.

He’s also younger than several other available hitters.

Chisholm, who spent last season with the Yankees, has tremendous ability. One can dream of a potential 30/30 season. But the question is whether he can consistently be a solid contributor and team player. His athleticism is intriguing, but his commitment is questionable at times.

Trade targets

Arizona Diamondbacks' Ketel Marte reacts after hitting a two-run home run against the Los Angeles Dodgers in the first inning of a baseball game, Sunday, Aug 9, 2026, in Phoenix. (AP Photo/Rick Scuteri) Arizona Diamondbacks' Ketel Marte reacts after hitting a two-run home run against the Los Angeles Dodgers in the first inning of a baseball game, Sunday, Aug 9, 2026, in Phoenix. (AP Photo/Rick Scuteri) (Rick Scuteri)

Ketel Marte, second baseman, Arizona Diamondbacks

Marte is the kind of player who could significantly change Toronto’s lineup. He is a switch-hitter with power, the ability to get on base and a history of producing in important situations. From a purely offensive standpoint, he’s an excellent fit.

But I would have serious reservations about acquiring him, and those concerns go well beyond his contract, or the prospects Arizona would demand. Marte went AWOL from the Diamondbacks in each of the past two seasons.

Arizona shopped him last off-season but couldn’t find the right deal, so they kept him. They seem committed to trading him this time around. He has veto rights on any trade though, because he has 10-and-5 rights. He can be acquired for less than what his talent warrants, but the Jays need to decide whether they want to deal with the potential headache.

Marte’s offensive ability is undeniable, but talent alone isn’t enough. With a contract extending through 2031, the Blue Jays would be assuming considerable risk.

Japanese posting market

Teruaki Sato, third baseman/outfielder, Hanshin Tigers

Sato is one of the more intriguing players available this winter.

The 27-year-old left-handed slugger won Japan’s Central League Triple Crown in 2026, hitting .306 with 39 home runs and 106 RBIs.

Sato does have considerable swing-and-miss in his game, but the success of Munetaka Murakami with the White Sox last season, who also has significant swing-and-miss, will empower teams to spend more on Sato than Murakami.

There’s also a positional issue. Sato fits at third base, first base and corner outfield. Hits bat is an easy fit, but his glove is not. Kazuma Okamoto is established at third base, Guerrero occupies first base, and Santander’s contract complicates the outfield picture.

The possibility of a lockout makes this an unusually complicated off-season. Owners are expected to pursue significant economic changes, potentially including a salary cap. The players’ association has historically opposed that concept.

If I’m a general manager, I have to consider what those changes might mean for contracts I’m negotiating today. However, I wouldn’t necessarily wait until the next CBA is settled. I would seek guidance from my owner and then aggressively pursue anyone my owner approved.

The Japanese posting system presents a unique challenge. Under normal circumstances, Japanese players have 45 days to negotiate with major-league teams once posted. This year, the expiration of the CBA on Dec. 1, shortens the window, as there is an expectation that the owners will lock out the players and there is no pausing the expiration of the window.

Ultimately, the Blue Jays need more than one offensive addition. They also need Guerrero to return to being an elite hitter after a disappointing 2026 season.

I’d prioritize Suzuki, pursue Lowe if his medical evaluations check out, and consider Arraez as a complementary piece. I’d explore Marte and Chisholm only after thoroughly investigating the clubhouse concerns and pursue Sato if there is a convincing defensive plan.

The Blue Jays have demonstrated they’re willing to spend money. Now they must demonstrate they can spend it wisely. Because regardless of what happens in the labour negotiations, one thing is certain: Toronto isn’t returning to the postseason unless it finds a way to score significantly more runs.