MLB
Tarik SkubalOpens in new window

Skubal to ...? What about other big free agents? How MLB offseason dominoes fall

Published: 

Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Tarik Skubal throws against the Detroit Tigers during the first inning of a baseball game Friday, Aug. 28, 2026, in Detroit. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya) (Paul Sancya/AP Photo/Paul Sancya)

The countdown to the impending lockout is getting closer, which means the MLB offseason will likely grind to a depressing halt when the clock hits midnight on Dec. 1. Until then, teams are continuing to act like it’s business as usual -- Jake Bauers to the Boston Red Sox, Dustin May to the Chicago White Sox and Evan Phillips to the Atlanta Braves have been the most significant free agent signings so far.

The big prize in a weak class is two-time Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal -- and he’s expected to sign before the sport shuts down. This happened prior to the last lockout following the 2021 season, when Corey Seager, Marcus Semien, Javier Baez, Max Scherzer, Robbie Ray and Kevin Gausman all signed $100 million-plus contracts before the lockout went into effect.

Skubal might be the only nine-figure free agent this year, but the ripple effect of where he lands will dictate the offseason.

Using Jeff Passan’s intel on what he’s hearing will happen over the next two weeks as a guideline, let’s kick off this offseason edition of dominoes with Skubal going ... East?

Tarik Skubal to New York Mets

The Mets are the favorite to land Skubal, according to Passan, in part because of the Los Angeles Dodgers’ desire for a shorter-term commitment. Of course, Skubal loved his time with L.A. and lives in Arizona in the offseason, so maybe the Dodgers will view this as a situation of “sign him while you can” and eventually give Skubal whatever it takes.

If the labor negotiations do eventually end up with some sort of capped system, this could be the last chance for the Dodgers to empty their bank vault for several years. Their primary need for their long-term future -- regardless of payroll rules -- is getting younger in the lineup (Andy Pages was the only regular younger than 30 years old) rather than adding more starting pitching. Instead of locking up another starter, they might be eyeing the free agent class following the 2029 season for their next big signing: Elly De La Cruz, Brice Turang, Jordan Walker and, if they want to dip into pitching, Paul Skenes.

Enter the Mets, a big-market team with money to spend while the rules permit, holes in the rotation to fill and losing ways to mend. They have two young rotation anchors in Nolan McLean and Christian Scott, but some of their veteran additions haven’t worked out, including last offseason’s trade for Freddy Peralta or Sean Manaea’s three-year deal two years ago. The Mets haven’t had a pitcher finish in the top five of the Cy Young voting since Jacob deGrom in 2020; they need Skubal more than the Dodgers need him.

Michael King to San Diego Padres

The Padres’ new owners appear willing to keep up the spending habits of the late Peter Seidler, so that’s the good news. The bad news is they need to fill at least three-fifths of a rotation, with King, Walker Buehler, Robbie Ray, Casey Mize and Nick Pivetta all free agents (Randy Vasquez is the lone holdover and they’re hoping for a comeback from Joe Musgrove, who returned in the postseason after missing two full seasons). Swiping Skubal from the Dodgers would be a double whammy -- helping yourselves while hurting your enemy -- but logic says the Padres need to spread the money around. Re-signing King, who has a 3.15 ERA in his three years in San Diego, should be the first step.

Trevor Rogers to Toronto Blue Jays

Are the Blue Jays interested in Skubal or are they interested in rotation help in general? Because after finishing last in the majors in runs scored, they definitely need to boost the lineup. Bottom line: After dropping to 79-83 in 2026, the Jays need to add an impact player or two no matter the position.

That might be Rogers, who ranks fifth among starting pitchers on ESPN’s ranking of the top 50 free agents -- behind Skubal, Peralta, Japanese right-hander Kaima Taira and King -- but he might be the best combination of age (he’s entering his age-29 season) and upside (3.16 ERA over the past two seasons).

Rogers isn’t overpowering, but he possesses a five-pitch mix and induces a ton of chase while issuing just 39 walks in 30 starts for the Baltimore Orioles this past season. He does have some injury history -- missing most of 2023 with biceps and shoulder issues, and he had a knee injury at the start of 2025 -- but that also means he doesn’t have a lot of wear on his left arm. The Blue Jays are dreaming of a Skubal/Dylan Cease combo, but Cease, Rogers, Jose Soriano and Trey Yesavage would rank as one of the top foursomes in the majors -- and there could still be room left to sign a hitter.

The one issue with Rogers is that he declined the qualifying offer the Orioles gave him, so the Blue Jays would lose their second- and fifth-highest draft picks as well as forfeit $1 million from their international pool money. Losing those picks will cool some teams on Rogers, but the Blue Jays, after coming so close in 2025, are determined to get back to the World Series.

Freddy Peralta to Baltimore Orioles

That leaves Peralta as the next pitcher in line. The Orioles “are everywhere,” Passan reported, and have a willingness to carry a top-10 payroll -- which, according to Cot’s Contracts, they last reached in 2005 (they were 14th in 2026). The Orioles were 17th in rotation ERA and face the prospect of losing Rogers, so they will be looking for a starter to join Shane Baz and Kyle Bradish to lead the rotation. This could be a best-case scenario: Rogers turned down the qualifying offer, so if he signs for more than $50 million with another team, the Orioles receive a draft pick at the end of the first round. Since Peralta was traded during his free agent season, he can be signed without any penalty.

Kaima Taira (and Clay Holmes) to Chicago Cubs

We know the Cubs need major help in terms of starting pitching -- they basically need to fill an entire rotation. Re-signing Holmes is a popular prediction, but they’ll need more than him. The Cubs haven’t signed a pitcher to a nine-figure deal since Yu Darvish in 2018, so that takes them out of the Skubal sweepstakes and perhaps Peralta as well, given his projected contract of four years, $96 million. They prefer not to sign free agents with qualifying offers, so that is likely to eliminate Rogers. The highest-ranked remaining starter would be the 5-foot-8 Taira, who had a 1.36 ERA in Japan in 2026.

Chicago went the Japan route three years and got three solid years from Shota Imanaga, but Taira has better stuff and shouldn’t be as prone to the home run. His projected contract is five years for $72.5 million.

Randy Arozarena to Philadelphia Phillies

Let’s move away from the pitching market to a big-market team looking to make a major signing. The Phillies need a hitter. Preferably right-handed. Preferably an outfielder. Preferably a good defender to help one of the more porous defenses in the majors. Perhaps someone who reportedly prefers to head back to the East Coast.

Passan reports that teams are balking at Arozarena’s $100 million asking price, but with an aging roster that needs to win now, the Phillies might be the one team willing to get close to nine figures -- after all, president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski isn’t one to shy away from paying to get the guy he wants.

Arozarena had an outstanding under-the-radar season in Seattle in 2026, posting 5.7 WAR and leading the American League in runs scored despite playing in a tough hitters’ park with a bad lineup around him. He’s gone 20/20 all six of his full seasons in the majors and has been extremely durable, averaging 154 games over the past five seasons. He’s a below-average defender in left field, but, hey, when do the Phillies care about defense anyway?

Seiya Suzuki to San Diego Padres

With Arozarena heading to the Phillies in our scenario, Suzuki is the next domino to fall ... going to San Diego. Besides their need for starting pitchers, the Padres have also been considering some of the bigger hitters, with Passan labeling the Padres the favorites to land Suzuki -- although, he also makes sense for the Seattle Mariners or returning to the Cubs.

Suzuki is coming off a .270/.368/.473 season with Chicago while posting the best defensive metrics of his career (88th percentile in outs above average and 94th percentile in arm value). A projected four-year, $90 million contract is steep for a player entering his age-32 season, but the Padres’ window is closing the older Manny Machado and Xander Bogaerts get (with years to go on each of their contracts). The Padres would play Suzuki in right field and move Fernando Tatis Jr. back to the infield, probably second base, where he started 50 games last season.

Jazz Chisholm Jr. to Toronto Blue Jays

After signing Rogers, the Blue Jays still have work to do. Arozarena and Suzuki are possibilities, but Chisholm, with a two-year, $46 million projection, is a less expensive and younger option. While the Yankees seem content to let him walk after inconsistent results at the plate and lack of focus, Chisholm has averaged 2.9 WAR over each of the past three seasons and is an excellent defender at second base (at least via Statcast). He was worth 4.1 WAR in 2025, when he hit 31 home runs, but fell off to 1.7 in 2026. The Jays could turn Ernie Clement back into a super utility guy to play Chisholm at second base, plus Chisholm has the ability to shift into the outfield as needed.

Brandon Lowe to New York Yankees

With David Bednar accepting the Yankees’ qualifying offer, general manager Brian Cashman can breathe a little easier about his bullpen and turn his attention to replacing Chisholm at second. Maybe Anthony Volpe is the guy. Or, after more than 2,000 plate appearances in the majors with an OPS+ of 83, maybe he’s not. Lowe is a big upgrade in power -- he has hit 66 home runs over the past two seasons -- and played the best defense of his career after changing his pre-pitch routine. While it would be wonderful to see the Pittsburgh Pirates re-sign Lowe, his projected four-year, $80 million contract is more likely to place him in the Bronx than next to the Roberto Clemente Bridge.

Teruaki Sato to Los Angeles Angels

It will be fascinating to see what kind of deal the Japanese slugger lands. He looks a lot like Munetaka Murakami did a year ago, and Murakami had to settle for a lower-than-expected two-year, $34 million contract with the White Sox. He hit .207 for them this past season, but with 35 home runs and a ton of walks and strikeouts. The overall offensive package was productive, although Murakami hit .156 the final two months. It’s hard to say how those results will affect the evaluations of Sato.

Sato was primarily a third baseman in Japan; if he can stay there, he could end up with the Phillies -- or the Yankees, except we have Lowe going to New York -- but most believe he’ll end up in left field or first base. Maybe, like Murakami, Sato ends up in a surprise destination. The Angels were 28th in the majors in OPS at third base and need to take a risk to boost the offense. If Sato’s defensive chops aren’t up to par at third base, they can try him in left field.

Adrian Morejon to Los Angeles Dodgers

Where does this leave the Dodgers? There are other good starting pitchers out there: Tyler Mahle, Nick Martinez, Gausman, Imanaga, Foster Griffin. Given that May’s deal with the White Sox is for three years and $52.5 million, much higher than expected, we’ll see if the market now explodes for this group. The Braves, San Francisco Giants and Houston Astros are among the teams in the mix here, along with the Cubs and Padres. The Tampa Bay Rays will need to re-sign Martinez or replace him. Luis Arraez and Ian Happ are the other top position players.

None of those players feel like a fit for the Dodgers. Morejon, however, is one of the top relievers in the game. The Dodgers already lost Phillips, and Alex Vesia is also a free agent, so they could use a high-leverage reliever -- yes, even though Edwin Diaz and Tanner Scott are already two of the game’s highest-paid relievers and signed for two more seasons.

Again, the rules might be changing. This could be one last chance for the Dodgers to play Moneyball.