NFL

Inside how one NFL ref crew worked two games in a day

Published: 

INDIANAPOLIS -- IT'S HARD to tell when an NFL referee is actually in a hurry because they're always jogging from here to there.

Jogging onto the field with a bag of footballs, jogging to take their position behind the quarterback, jogging over to the replay monitor to screen a review. But at 4:37 p.m. ET Sunday at Lucas Oil Stadium, when referee Don Willard power-walks with his suitcase and bag through the concrete bowels of the stadium, led by a police officer and flanked by three other game officials and an NFL security staffer, it's clear that he is in a hurry.

"Next stop: Beep! Beep!" umpire Terry Killens yells as the group walks out of the official's locker room in street clothes.

Kickoff for their second NFL game of the day is less than four hours away, and Cincinnati is still two hours down the dark and construction-interrupted I-74. The crew has a police escort to the highway and then they'll be on their own. Willard, Killens, field judge Jabir Walker and side judge Joe Larrew hold their snack boxes in one hand and roll their small suitcases with the other. Willard totes a pink Pedialyte -- necessary for replenishing the 3 hours and 13 minutes of intense focus he had just put in. Larrew munches on a cookie while he walks and then accidentally drops it on the floor.

Two stadium security workers wave goodbye and yell, "Drive safe!" But these four VIPs won't be driving themselves anywhere. A black sprinter van waits for the entourage, tucked just behind the Dolphins' team buses. Another stadium security worker escorts a CBS videographer into the area to capture their departure. He backpedals to get the perfect shot: four officials boarding a van that will take them from Indianapolis (where the Colts defeated the Dolphins 24-22) to Cincinnati for the Bengals' Sunday night game against the Steelers -- pulling double duty to officiate two NFL games on the same day.

The security worker tells another stadium worker, "Wow, this is really a big deal, huh?" He explains that the CBS camera he has shepherded into place is going to send its footage to NBC's "Sunday Night Football" broadcast (which will later highlight the feat).

The NFL declined ESPN's request to speak to the four officials and Ramon George, the league's head of officiating training and development, who was responsible for sorting through the travel disaster created by the FAA's nationwide ground stop Friday.

George worked through the night Friday to create new crews for each game based on geographic convenience so the game officials didn't need to use unreliable air travel. The result was flip-card changes for the game officials that were longer than the inactive players lists.

Each of the four double-duty referees work on different crews. At the Sunday night game, the inactives sheet handed out to the media pregame featured an entirely different crew of the seven on-field officials than what had been previously slated, with the parenthetical "the instant replay official still is Chad Adams."

The situation is likely unprecedented in NFL history because it's risky. The league intentionally arranges for officials to travel on the day before games (except in the case of international games, for which they travel further in advance), so they are settled and adjusted to a different time zone and can get good rest before they work.

Former NFL vice president of officiating and current Fox rules analyst Dean Blandino told ESPN that when he was running the department, having a game official work two games on the same day "would be the last resort," which shows how extreme the circumstances were. Typically an emergency alternate scenario would impact one crew and two officials, not the entire 17-crew system.

"I am sure they went through all the different iterations and exhausted every option," Blandino said.

Blandino said officiating two games in one day is the last resort because "it would be like playing two football games back-to-back. There's the physical aspect of running and the mental exhaustion after a game because you are doing a pre-snap routine for every snap, and then the eight-second play, and then a post-snap routine.

"The officials look like they are not exerting themselves the same way the players are, but they don't get breaks. They don't play one side of the ball. They are out there every snap and every kick. Then to say now I have to reset without any recovery time? That is a challenge."

"It's exhausting because you're looking for something on every single play," said Russell Yurk, ESPN's rules analyst and former VP of replay for the league office. "You're analyzing every single play. You're watching your players. You're watching your keys, you're making judgment calls, and it doesn't really let up the entire game."

1:03 p.m.

Kickoff in Indianapolis. Willard, normally a side judge, has never refereed a regular-season NFL game before, only preseason games and Big Ten conference matchups before he began working for the NFL in 2018. So when he first speaks into the microphone at Lucas Oil Stadium to announce the coin toss, it sounds weird, because his voice is totally unfamiliar.

Following Willard's announcement of an illegal formation penalty that the Colts declined, CBS analyst Spero Dedes says, "I think we need to lower the volume on the officiating mic -- he is interfering with our call."

Walker, the field judge, calls two Miami field goals wide left, and an extra point is no good.

2:40 p.m.

Willard and Dolphins coach Jeff Hafley have a spirited conversation with a lot of hand gesturing on Miami's sideline before the second half kicks off.

On the first play of the second half, Willard's instincts are tested. Colts cornerback Justin Walley hits Dolphins quarterback Kyle McCord in the back of his throwing arm. McCord loses the ball with his arm drawn back, poised to throw. The Colts recover in the end zone for a touchdown. But is it a fumble or did he already start to move his arm forward? Willard throws his blue bean bag to mark the spot of the fumble and calls it a fumble recovery touchdown for Indianapolis.

"This is a tough play, because Walley comes behind Kyle McCord and it's the defensive arm that really hits the ball and makes it go forward. As an official you think that ball is going forward because of the pass," said Gene Steratore, a retired official and CBS rules analyst. "But Don has fumble all the way, and it's a great job by him."

Colts tight end Alec Ogletree gets to talking with Willard during a break. "Are you one of the ones going to Cincy after this?" he asks.

Yep, that's us, Willard tells him.

Ogletree knew there were going to be changes to the crew because on Friday, the Colts had gone over information about the officiating crew as a team, but it was all with an asterisk: it was only who they thought would be working the game.

"But we didn't really know who was going to be out there till we got out here," Ogletree said.

"I did ask [Willard], 'So how long you been the ref, like head ref?' He's like, 'First game.'"

3:07 p.m.

Miami cornerback Chris Johnson picks off Daniel Jones at the 59-yard line and runs it back for a touchdown. Willard is standing at the Indianapolis 42, behind the quarterback as he throws, then runs that same distance back to the end zone to keep the play in front of him.

4:16 p.m.

The first game ends after three hours and 13 minutes -- a long one because Miami kept it close. The double-duty refs shower and change into street clothes for their trip to Cincinnati. They've all packed a second uniform, this one for an outdoor game. It will be much colder at Paycor Stadium.

6:37 p.m.

The weary travelers arrive at Paycor Stadium and bring their luggage straight into the security meeting at the 100-minute mark before game time. Willard carries a massage gun with him, hinting that his focus on the bus ride was as much about recovery as anything else.

"They're going to be tired tonight," says a team staffer as the refs pass by. Still wearing their civilian clothes, Walker and Larrew split up to attend their pregame meetings.

8:12 p.m.

The crew leaves the locker room to get the game started. They have to weave through a maze of Bengals players filling up the tunnel waiting for their names to be called for introductions. Willard's uniform jacket says "SJ" (side judge, his normal role) on the back.

10 p.m.

Killens bends over and stretches as he stands over the ball during a break in the game -- the only visible sign that these four might be feeling fatigued.

11:22 p.m. The AFC North matchup turns chippy, and Killens, a former NFL linebacker, breaks up two players before they take it too far, physically intervening at the end of the 13th hour of his workday.

11:24 p.m. Killens is the first to jog off the field. He lets out a sigh of relief as he turns the corner to the officials' locker room. Walker calmly and quietly follows behind. Willard brings up the rear and someone yells to him: "Can I get your step count?"

"I don't have it," he says, laughing.

The final stats: 242 plays, 6 hours and 15 minutes, 30 penalties officiated, three challenges reviewed (two reversed), and zero major controversial decisions, one Pedialyte consumed, unknown step count.

Killens stands at the door of the official's locker room, in front of the sign that says "POSITIVELY NO VISITORS" and he whoops and daps up each official that walks into the room. Officials can't win the game; it's not that kind of cheering. This wasn't just another regular season game. It looks and sounds like they are reveling in the completion of their daunting task. The mood seems much more celebratory than a typical postgame officials locker room. But then again, when have we ever bothered to pay attention to the officials' locker room postgame? Maybe they're always like this.

12 a.m.

The 14-hour workday is over. Police escort the officials to transportation to take them to their hotel. Because the league office has not approved any interviews, we may never know the answer to the most pressing question. How much does your brain hurt right now?

Brooke Pryor contributed to this story.