Scoreboard

Oct 20, 2014

Chasing Peyton: Where active quarterbacks rank behind Manning on all-time TD list

With four touchdown passes on Sunday night, Peyton Manning became the NFL's all-time leader in touchdown throws, surpassing Brett Favre's 508. At 510 and counting, Manning has more than 100 touchdowns more than any active player in the league. TSN.ca breaks down the players chasing Manning and their chances of catching him.

Peyton Manning

With four touchdown passes on Sunday night, Peyton Manning became the NFL's all-time leader in touchdown throws, surpassing Brett Favre's 508. At 510 passes and counting, Manning has more than 100 touchdowns more than any active player in the league. TSN.ca breaks down the players chasing Manning and their chances of catching him.

 

Alone at the Top

Peyton Manning
Peyton Manning

Denver Broncos

  • Touchdowns
    510
  • Age
    38
  • Active Rank
    1
  • All-Time Rank
    1
Manning set the touchdown record on October 19, 2014 with four touchdown passes against the San Francisco 49ers, passing Brett Favre's record of 508.

The 300-Club

Drew Brees
Drew Brees

New Orleans Saints

  • Touchdowns
    374
  • Age
    35
  • Active Rank
    2
  • All-Time Rank
    4
Perhaps the only quarterback with a legitimate chance to pass Manning within the next decade, Brees has posted three straight seasons of 39 or more passing touchdowns in the Saints high-powered offence.  Working against Brees is his age - Brees is just three younger than Manning - and his slow start to the 2014 season, Brees is on pace for 33 touchdowns this season, which would be his lowest total since 2010.
Tom Brady
Tom Brady

New England Patriots

  • Touchdowns
    372
  • Age
    37
  • Active Rank
    3
  • All-Time Rank
    5
At the age of 37, Tom Brady is unlikely to provide competition for Manning's record. Brady has not posted a 40-touchdown season since his record-setting 50 touchdowns in 2007, and is unlikely to do so this year. Brady will, however, likely pass Dan Marino's 420 passing touchdown mark before his career is over.

Next Best Shots

Aaron Rodgers
Aaron Rodgers

Green Bay Packers

  • Touchdowns
    206
  • Age
    30
  • Active Rank
    9
  • All-Time Rank
    35
Considering he didn't start for three seasons after being drafted in the first round, Aaron Rodgers has scored touchdowns at a torrid pace. In his first seven seasons as the Packers quarterback, Rodgers threw 188 touchdown passes, an average of 26 per season despite missing half of the 2013 campaign. Rodgers is once again on pace for 40-touchdown season in 2014 and if the quarterback can sustain his health through the age 40 or more, he could challenge Peyton.
Matthew Stafford
Matthew Stafford

Detroit Lions

  • Touchdowns
    118
  • Age
    26
  • Active Rank
    17
  • All-Time Rank
    108
Matt Stafford battled injuries throughout his first two NFL seasons, but has since started every game through his past three seasons. Earning his start at age 21 has given Stafford a jump on the field of Luck, Newton and Wilson. Considering his age and current mark, Stafford is probably the most likely active player to catch Peyton's final record first.

The Young Guns

Andrew Luck
Andrew Luck

Indianapolis Colts

  • Touchdowns
    65
  • Age
    25
  • Active Rank
    28
  • All-Time Rank
    164
It seems only right that Manning's successor in Indianapolis could be the next to set the touchdown mark. After posting 23 touchdowns in each of his first two NFL seasons, Luck has thrown 19 TDs through seven games in 2014 and appears to be ready to challenge the NFL's elite. Though the future remains unpredictable, if Luck maintains his 43-touchdown pace for this season and consistently posts 30 or more touchdowns a year moving forward, Luck could reach Manning by the time or before he hits the record holder's age at 38.
Cam Newton
Cam Newton

Carolina Panthers

  • Touchdowns
    72
  • Age
    25
  • Active Rank
    26
  • All-Time Rank
    157
Newton has a far way to go but his 72 touchdowns since entering the league in 2011 is a strong start. However, durability concerns and working in an offence with less passing weapons than Luck could see Newton passed by another young quarterback. 
Russell Wilson
Russell Wilson

Seattle Seahawks

  • Touchdowns
    62
  • Age
    26
  • Active Rank
    29
  • All-Time Rank
    170
Though Wilson is almost even with Luck in touchdowns, the 2012 third-round pick should be viewed as less likely to reach Manning than the Colts quarterback. Wilson is one year older than Luck and currently operates in a run-first offence.

The Unlikely

Eli Manning
Eli Manning

New York Giants

  • Touchdowns
    243
  • Age
    33
  • Active Rank
    4
  • All-Time Rank
    18
At age 32, Eli Manning is unlikely to challenge his brother's mark. Eli has also posted just one 30-touchdown season in his career.
Philip Rivers
Philip Rivers

San Diego Chargers

  • Touchdowns
    238
  • Age
    33
  • Active Rank
    5
  • All-Time Rank
    21
Philip Rivers has thrown at least 26 touchdowns in every season since 2008, yet like many others Rivers' age works against him. He also sat behind Brees for two seasons before earning his first start in San Diego. 
Ben Roethlisberger
Ben Roethlisberger

Pittsburgh Steelers

  • Touchdowns
    227
  • Age
    32
  • Active Rank
    6
  • All-Time Rank
    26
With Aaron Rodgers quickly gaining ground and several injury riddled seasons in his past, Roethlisberger should be considered a long shot to reach Manning.

Other Starting Quarterbacks

 
Name Touchdowns Age Active Rank All-Time Rank
Tony Romo 222  34  27
Carson Palmer  219 35  8 28 
Jay Cutler 169  31  11  61 
Matt Ryan 166  29  13  63 
Joe Flacco 135 29  14  88
Alex Smith  113  30  18  114 
Andy Dalton 86  27  24  142 
Ryan Tannehill 46  26  35  203
Nick Foles  43 28  36  212
Colin Kaepernick  42  27  37  216